Film vs Film
Select two cult films to compare side by side.
A Woman's Experience Synopsis
George and Alice Roydant live in the country with her wealthy uncle Nicholas Barrable, who wants to keep them from the city's temptations. After they become bored and move to New York, George neglects Alice as he successfully speculates on the market. He becomes involved with Attlie Damuron, an adventuress who soon begins to blackmail him. After George, upset at his situation, angrily rebukes Alice, she decides to accept the advances of Lord Sulgrave, a guest in their home. She sends him a note to come to her bedroom, but when he knocks, she regains her self-respect and refuses to allow him to enter. Sulgrave forces his way in, and after struggling with her, accidentally drinks her sleeping potion and dies. After George confesses his trouble with Attlie, Alice makes it appear that Sulgrave poisoned himself in his own room. Finally, Barrable arrives and helps them financially, they return to the country, and vow never to stray again.
The Secret of Eve Synopsis
Hagar, a gypsy woman, is determined that her child, Eve, shall have a better chance for happiness than her wandering life has afforded her. She leaves her baby on the doorstep of a Quaker family, the Fothergills and little Eve is brought up as their daughter. The ways of the Quakers pall upon Eve when she grows up. She sees merrymaking in the home of the Brandons one evening, and lured by the lights, peers in at the window. The gay crowd notice the Quaker girl, draw her into the house, and amuse themselves by dressing her up in finery. She confesses her loneliness to Arthur Brandon, who tells her of the fascinations of a great city. As their friendship grows, he asks her to marry him. She consents, and for a time revels in gaiety. But it finally becomes clear to her that there is no real happiness in such a life. Brandon is a factory owner, and he is conscienceless in his treatment of his workers. Eve is humiliated by the denunciations of her husband that appear in the newspapers. He also drinks heavily. Richard Blair, a young philanthropist, starts an investigation. While he is visiting Brandon's factory an Italian child, Rosa, is blinded by an accident. Rosa is granted a miserable pittance in compensation for the accident, and Blair tries to force Brandon to do more for her. He refuses. Blair finds work for Beppo, Rosa's father, and sends the child to an institute for the blind. Eve admires the nobility of Blair's nature. Brandon, misunderstanding the friendship of the two, insults her in the presence of Blair, who knocks him down. Eve offers to go away with Blair. He says he loves her. but he will not take her unlawfully. She will not return to her husband, so she goes to the city to fight her own way. She soon finds out, however, that she is unfit for the rough work she undertakes. Deciding that suicide is her only way out, she goes to a park lake intending to drown herself. She hears a girl calling out in distress, and sees the child, who is blind, walking toward the lake. Eve goes to her and finds it is Rosa, who has wandered away from the other children. Eve takes her back to the Institute. Beppo has never ceased to seek for revenge against Brandon. He follows him on board his motorboat, and when the boat is well away from shore he attacks Brandon and tries to kill him. An oil lamp is overturned. It sets fire to the boat, and both men, fearfully burned, sink to the bottom of the bay locked in a death grasp. Blair goes to Eve and tells her the news of her husband's death, saying that the way is now open for them to marry. But Eve's heart is bound up in the welfare of the blind children among whom she has cast her lot. She accepts a position as an attendant at the institute, to give her life to the little ones through whom she has at last discovered the secret of true happiness.
"A Woman's Experience" holds a slight edge in general audience appreciation, but "The Secret of Eve" offers its own unique cult appeal.
Suggested Watch:
A Woman's Experience