Film vs Film
Select two cult films to compare side by side.
The Impostor Synopsis
Sir Anthony Gregson, Bart., a wealthy mine owner, is unpopular with his employees, because of his unreasonable temper and lack of sympathy. Sir Anthony has one son, Aubrey, a lovable young man, who has angered his father by refusing to follow the latter's dictation in the matter of his marriage. Sir Anthony also has a twin brother, whom he has not seen for years. The brother, who has humble associates, is known among them as "Blink." Blink is married to a gypsy girl, known as "The Tearer." Sir Anthony makes a sea trip to benefit his health. By chance the yacht anchors off the coast where Blink has his hut. Sir Anthony accepts his brother's invitation to call on him, and while at Blink's hut he has a stroke of paralysis, and dies. Blink changes clothes with Sir Anthony, and taking advantage of his striking likeness to the other man, impersonates him. He proceeds to the yacht, taking "The Tearer" with him, pretending she is Miss Gibson, his trained nurse. Blink, as Sir Anthony, sails homeward with his "trained nurse." The first thing he does is to call on Mary Priestly with Miss Gibson. Miss Gibson tells Mary that she wishes to marry Sir Anthony, but will not take this step without first getting the consent of Aubrey. Sir Anthony (Blink) is apparently reconciled to his son and gives him his consent to marry Mary. Aubrey, of course, gives his consent in return. The troubles in the mines have reached a climax. The men have struck because of small wages and unsafe equipment. The men are enraged against Sir Anthony. To quell the disturbance, Blink, as Sir Anthony, agrees to look over the mines and investigate. This he does, taking Aubrey and Miss Gibson with him. After he investigates, he orders that new and safe equipment shall be bought, and that the miners' wages shall be raised. All this while Gouger, the friend of Blink in his former life, has been trying to see the man he thinks is Sir Anthony. Having found Sir Anthony dead in Blink's hut, he thinks that Sir Anthony has killed Blink and eloped with "The Tearer." Gouger is eager for revenge. He finds "The Tearer" and says that he wishes to have an interview with Sir Anthony. "The Tearer" (Miss Gibson), frightened for Blink's life, keeps putting Gouger off. At last, however, Blink (Sir Anthony) agrees to see him. Aubrey, Mary and Miss Gibson are in the room. To satisfy Gouger it is necessary for Blink to disclose his identity before Aubrey. This, of course, satisfies Gouger. Aubrey does not mind, as he has grown to love Blink. Blink again marries "The Tearer" for appearance's sake, and Aubrey marries Mary Priestly.
Germinal; or, The Toll of Labor Synopsis
The mechanic Etienne Lantier is a competent workman out of a job, whose tempestuous disposition is more than atoned for by a good heart. With bundle in hand he looks for work from town to town and in vain until he comes to the coal mines of Montsou. Luckily for him there is a vacancy because of a workman being absent, and the foreman, Maheu, hires him at the suggestion of his daughter, Catherine, who dressed as a man is wont to work like a man in the mine. Lantier creates an impression on her and she takes his part much to the chagrin of her accepted lover, Chaval, an unworthy and violent man. Lantier fails to recognize her as a woman until after sharing her lunch with him in the depths of the mine, her hair falls from under her miner's headgear. From that moment he devotes his whole heart to her. At the end of the day's labor Lantier, who has excited a fierce jealousy in Chaval, is invited by Maheu to become a boarder at his house and he joyfully accepts. The engineer, Negrel, making his daily descent into the mine finds the shoring timbers holding up the earth in a bad state and ready to fall. He makes a report recommending that the woodwork he immediately and properly repaired so as to avoid accident. The company, however, posts a notice saying that because the woodwork has to be repaired the price received by the miners per car of coal mined will be decreased. This arbitrary and unfair notice causes much discontent and anger among the miners. A mass meeting is called for at the Cabaret Rasseneur; Souvarine, an anarchistic workman, advocates violent measures. Lantier opposes this and suggests concerted action. The anger of the workmen breaks out afresh when they begin to receive their reduced wages and urged on by Lantier, whose influence is growing, they vote to strike. In the meantime Catherine, though in love with Lantier, dares not go back on her word to Chaval and marries him. Chaval treacherously carries full information of the strike proceedings to Mr. Hennebeau, the chief director of the company, and accepts pay for being a spy. The strike is now on amid general enthusiasm. In the meantime, Negrel, the engineer, who is in love with Hennebeau's daughter, pleads with Hennebeau to answer the miners' requests. Miss Hennebeau also pleads with her father, but in vain. The stores refuse to extend credit to the striking workmen and famine soon stalks among them. Lantier discovers to his surprise that Chaval is an exception and that he has plenty of food and money. As yet he has not discovered that Chaval is the paid spy of the company. Catherine brings secretly to her starving relative food and money. Chaval follows her, drives her from the house and strikes her. Lantier seeing it interferes in her behalf, and being attacked by Chaval thoroughly thrashes him. Chaval, taking advantage of the growing misery among the miners, urges some of them back to work. While they are in the mines the other strikers cut the elevator ropes. There is a panic in the mine depths. The imprisoned miners finally escape by ladders, but have to run the gauntlet of the enraged strikers, who still hold out. When Chaval is dragged from the mine Lantier rashes at him, but Catherine steps in between and prevents harm being done to her husband. Blinded by hatred Chaval goes to Hennebeau and denounces the miners' leaders, especially Lantier. The police are called upon to arrest him, but warned in time he escapes to the abandoned shaft of Voroux. The strike becomes violent and the troops are called in to reinforce the police. In the absence of Lantier, Souvarine is called in to head the strikers. Hennebeau's house is attacked and stoned. Seeing the soldiers preparing to fire on the mob, the director's daughter rushes from the house to try and avert the coming calamity. She is caught in the storm of bullets and dies together with many of the miners and their wives, among them Catherine's father. This crushes the strikers' movement and instigated by Chaval they vote to resume work. Lantier, emerged from his refuge, tries in vain to dissuade them, but his influence is gone and bowing to the majority he also goes back to work. Souvarine, alone implacable, determines upon desperate measures. He releases the bolts binding the barriers that hold back water from flooding the mine and the flood breaks loose. He is drowned in the cataclysm that follows. The miners, caught like rats in a trap, run madly hither and thither. Some escape, others, among them Lantier, Catherine and Chaval, are caught. These latter three find themselves imprisoned in an abandoned working pit, where they sit in despair with the water up to their knees. They have little food and when after long hours Catherine attempts to give a little of her lunch to Lantier. Chaval furiously opposes. Chaval finally attempts to deprive his wife by force of her morsel of food. In righteous rage Lantier strikes him and kills him. His dead body, floating on the water, haunts them. Forgetting their animosities, directors and workmen unite in the work of rescue. Through an abandoned pit they come near to Catherine and Lantier. Their signals being answered by the prisoners they redouble their exertions. By imprudence, however, an explosion takes place, which kills many of the rescuers and sets back the work. Among those killed is Catherine's brother. When the workers finally pierce the intervening walls they find only Lantier alive, for Catherine lies dead in his arms. When the unconscious man is brought into the daylight and at last opens his eyes it is the bereaved Negrel who, with a heart of sympathy, comforts him in his grief when he sees the body of his dead sweetheart. Broken in spirit he sees injustice rule and the poor pay the piper.
"Germinal; or, The Toll of Labor" is currently leading in ratings, making it a stronger choice for newcomers to the genre.
Suggested Watch:
The Impostor