DbcultAccessing Vault...
6.6/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 6.6/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Big City Fantasy remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Honestly? Only if you have a thing for vintage musical shorts that feel like they were made in a different universe. If you enjoy Hoboken to Hollywood or just like staring at old footage of the Bowery while an orchestra plays, you'll be fine. If you want a plot that actually moves, you'll probably want to turn it off after the first five minutes. It’s not really a movie as much as it is a weird, staged fever dream. 🎷
The whole thing kicks off with Phil Spitalny’s orchestra just kind of… hanging out. They play for about three minutes straight. It’s loud, it’s brassy, and it feels like the movie is just stalling for time before it actually starts.
Once the singer starts her "fantasies," the pacing gets really strange. She’s wandering through NYC neighborhoods like she’s on a very confusing scavenger hunt. The music shifts to match wherever she is, which is a neat trick, but it feels so forced. Like, is that really how you find your family? By listening for specific cultural folk songs in random restaurants? It’s a bold strategy.
I caught myself wondering if the singer ever actually stopped to buy a coffee, or if she just walked until the plot decided she was tired. The movie feels like it was put together by someone who had never been to New York but had read a very confusing brochure about it.
It’s nowhere near the scope of Mysteries of India, Part I: Truth, obviously. It’s just a tiny, dusty scrap of a film. It’s a strange little artifact that doesn’t really care if you keep up with it or not. Sometimes you just need to let the brass section do the heavy lifting for you.
