5.8/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 5.8/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Der Schuß im Tonfilmatelier remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
You should probably watch this if you’re the kind of person who likes seeing how the sausage gets made. It’s a great pick for a rainy Sunday afternoon when you want something moody but not too heavy. If you hate slow-moving plots or black-and-white films where people talk a bit too loud, you’ll probably find this boring as hell.
The whole thing takes place in a movie studio during the early days of sound. They are filming a scene about a guy who is jealous of his girlfriend. Then, bang, a real shot goes off and someone is actually dead on the floor.
It’s very meta. You get to see the giant, clunky microphones and the way the directors used to yell at everyone. I honestly found the background details of the studio more interesting than the actual murder mystery part. 🎥
The lead actor, played by Hans Ritter, is the main suspect because he was dating the victim and is now engaged to the other star. Talk about a bad day at work. He spends most of the movie looking like he’s about to faint, which I guess is fair under the circumstances.
There is this one moment where the camera lingers on a microphone hanging from a crane for way too long. It feels like the movie is trying to brag about having sound technology. It’s kind of funny how proud they were of those big, ugly metal boxes.
The writing is actually better than you’d expect for a random 1930s flick. That’s probably because Curt Siodmak helped write it. He’s the guy who later did some famous sci-fi stuff, so he knows how to build a bit of tension.
It reminds me a little of the vibe in The Crash, but with more German shouting. The studio itself feels like a character, all dark corners and weird wires everywhere.
One of the actors, Paul Kemp, is actually pretty funny as the comic relief. He has this way of moving his face that makes you forget there’s a dead body in the next room. I think he’s the best part of the whole cast, to be honest.
The pacing gets a bit weird in the middle. There’s a lot of people standing around in offices talking about police reports. It’s not exactly a high-speed chase, you know? It’s more like a very slow walk through a very dusty room.
I noticed that the female star, Gerda Maurus, has these incredibly intense eyes. Every time the camera gets close to her, the movie feels ten times more serious. She’s way better than some of the stuff in Strange Cargo.
The police in this movie are... not great at their jobs. They seem to just believe whoever talked to them last. It’s a miracle they ever solve anything in these old films.
There is a scene with a telephone that goes on for about three minutes. Just a guy talking into a phone while the camera stays perfectly still. It’s almost hypnotic if you don't fall asleep first. ☎️
I liked how they used the lighting. Since it’s a movie set, they have an excuse to have these dramatic shadows everywhere. It makes the whole thing feel much more expensive than it probably was.
If you've seen Michael, you know how those early European films can be really slow but beautiful. This isn't quite on that level, but it has its moments of style.
The ending is a bit of a rush. They basically just point at the killer and say "It was you!" and then it's over. I would of liked a bit more of a buildup, but I guess they were running out of film.
It’s definitely a better time than Henpecked. That one was just exhausting to get through. This one at least has a murder to keep you awake.
One weird thing—the way they handle the "jealousy scene" is so over-the-top. The actors in the movie-within-the-movie are chewing the scenery so hard it's a wonder there's any left. It makes you realize how much acting has changed since 1930.
The sound quality is a bit scratchy, obviously. Sometimes you can barely hear what they are saying over the hiss of the background noise. It adds to the atmosphere, though, in a strange way.
I wouldn't call it a masterpiece or anything. It’s just a solid, slightly clunky mystery that lets you peek into a world that doesn't exist anymore. It’s like finding an old photo in an attic—kind of dusty, but you can’t stop looking at it.
Anyway, if you like seeing people in tuxedos looking worried in a studio, give it a go. It’s got more personality than half the stuff they put out now. Just don't expect a twist that will blow your mind.
Oh, and look out for the scene where the script girl gets annoyed. It’s the most relatable thing in the whole movie.

IMDb —
1924
Community
Log in to comment.