5.5/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 5.5/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. His Private Secretary remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you have a soft spot for grainy, pre-code era romantic comedies where everyone speaks at double speed, then sure. It’s got a weird energy. If you’re looking for a serious John Wayne western, keep walking. This is just a goofy office comedy that feels like it was written on the back of a napkin in twenty minutes.
The whole premise is so silly it hurts. Dick Wallace (the Duke himself, looking young and confused) marries a girl in secret. Then she gets a job at his dad's firm. It’s basically a recipe for every possible cliché from 1933.
Wait, did I mention the office set? It looks like it was made of cardboard and hope. There’s a scene where John Wayne leans against a desk and it honestly looks like it might collapse under his weight. It’s very distracting.
Evalyn Knapp is trying her best here. She’s got this sharp, fast-talking delivery that keeps the movie from completely stalling out. She has to carry the heavy lifting while everyone else just sort of wanders through the scenes.
There’s a weird vibe here, kind of like when I watched Watch Your Husbands. Everything feels a bit loose, like they knew it wasn't a masterpiece so they just leaned into the absurdity. It’s not as polished as something like The Belle of New York, that’s for sure.
The pacing is a disaster. Sometimes a scene ends before you realize it started. Other times, a conversation goes on for an eternity while two people just stare at each other. It’s almost hypnotizing in its unevenness. 😵💫
Is it great? No. Is it boring? Sometimes. But there’s something genuinely sweet about the way it just refuses to be taken seriously. It’s not trying to be a The Awakening or some grand dramatic statement. It just wants to get to the next punchline, even if the punchline doesn't always land.
If you're in the mood for something light that won't ask much of your brain, this is fine. Just don't expect to remember much about it by tomorrow morning. It’s a perfectly average relic of a very strange time in Hollywood.

IMDb 5.2
1931
Community
Log in to comment.