Cult Review
Senior Film Conservator

Honestly, only if you are a completionist for early French cinema or have a weird obsession with period costumes that look like they haven't been ironed since the 1930s. If you want something snappy, skip this. If you enjoy watching people look sad in fancy rooms while whispering about duty, you might find a bit of charm here.
The whole thing feels like it’s draped in a thick layer of velvet curtains. Everyone is constantly whispering. I found myself cranking the volume up just to hear the dialogue, only to realize I wasn't missing much anyway. It’s all about the 'dignity of the throne' and other stuff that felt like a chore even back then.
Natalie Paley carries a certain sadness in her eyes that feels real, even when the script forces her into these rigid, awkward poses. There’s a scene near the middle where she just stands by a window for what feels like ten minutes. It’s not poetic. It’s just quiet. 🕰️
It’s funny, watching this reminded me of For the Queen's Honor, but with significantly less swordplay and way more sighing. The stakes feel low, even when the music swells to tell you that something "important" is happening. You can almost see the actors waiting for their cues to look devastated.
The pacing is a mess. It’s not that it's slow—it’s that it’s stagnant. It just stops. It sits there. You find yourself checking your phone, and then you look up and someone is still standing in that same room, holding a letter. It’s a bit hypnotic, I guess, if you’re trying to fall asleep.
I don't think anyone involved was trying to make a masterpiece. It feels like a job they did on a Tuesday. The sets look like they were recycled from The Tiny Kingdom of Montenegro or something similar. Everything feels dusty.
Anyway, I probably wouldn't watch it again. It’s one of those movies that exists, and that’s about all you can say for it. It lacks the punch you’d find in something like Die Welt ohne Maske, where at least the visual style keeps you awake. Here, it’s just people talking about who they can't marry. 😴

IMDb —
1917
Community
Log in to comment.