Cult Review
Senior Film Conservator

If you have a weird itch to see how people in the 1930s thought 'modern' girls acted, sure, give it a whirl. If you’re looking for a plot that doesn't feel like it’s being held together by loose tape and optimism, maybe skip it. It’s for the folks who like digging through film archives just to see what the wallpaper looked like in a Berlin apartment ninety years ago. Everyone else will probably be asleep by the twenty-minute mark.
The whole thing feels oddly detached. Like the actors are constantly waiting for a bus that never arrives. There's this scene where they’re all sitting around a table, and the blocking is so rigid it feels like a military drill disguised as a casual brunch. I kept waiting for someone to just trip over a chair or sneeze, just to prove they were actually human.
You’ve seen this setup a thousand times before. Someone wants a career, someone wants a boy, and the world is just loud enough to be annoying. It reminded me a bit of the frantic, slightly disjointed energy you find in Changing Husbands, though without the same level of charm. The pacing is just… strange. It skips over the bits you actually want to see and lingers on shots of curtains blowing in the wind.
The music is fine, I guess. It’s that jaunty, brassy stuff that makes you feel like you’re watching a newsreel about a new bridge opening. Sometimes it works, but then there are moments where the music just keeps playing while the characters stare at each other. It’s awkward. I think it’s meant to be romantic. It’s mostly just quiet.
There's a moment midway through where the camera just stays on a street scene for no apparent reason. No characters. Just cars and people walking by. It felt like the director just decided he was done with the scene and went to get coffee. Honestly? It was the most honest part of the whole film. ☕
If you’ve seen The Charmer, you know how thin the line between 'dashing lead' and 'mildly creepy guy' can be. This film walks that line with its eyes closed. Some of the interactions between the men and the women made me want to look away from my laptop. Not because it’s offensive, just because it’s so performative. Like everyone is reading from a manual on how to be a person.
It’s not a bad movie. It’s just… a thin one. It exists. It takes up space. It occupies a folder on a hard drive somewhere. And sometimes, that’s all a movie needs to do to be worth a look on a rainy Tuesday. Just don't go in expecting to be changed by it. You’ll be looking at the clock. A lot.

IMDb —
1923
Community
Log in to comment.