6.3/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 6.3/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Quaint Quebec remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you have nine minutes to spare and a weird obsession with old film reels, Quaint Quebec is actually a pretty neat watch. History buffs and people who like looking at vintage postcards will dig it. But if you want actual plot or drama, you will probably fall asleep in about two minutes flat. 😴
It is basically a 1930s tourism brochure brought to life. The narrator, Benjamin D. Sharpe, has that incredibly specific, ultra-proper voice that makes you feel like you are sitting in a chilly school classroom in 1936.
Sharpe talks about the Plains of Abraham and the Hotel Frontenac with this weirdly intense gravity. Like he is explaining the secrets of the universe, not just a fancy hotel lobby. 🏨
There is this one shot of the St. Lawrence River where the camera just... wobbles. It is clearly a mistake, but they kept it in anyway. I love little errors like that in these old shorts because it makes you realize some guy was actually hauling a massive, heavy camera around on a windy day.
We also get a super quick look at the St. Louis Bridge and the House of Parliament. Honestly, the editing is so fast it feels like the director was running out of physical film. Or maybe they just really wanted to pack up and get lunch.
It is funny comparing this to actual narrative movies from the era, like London After Dark or even a melodrama like Turn Back the Clock. Those films tried so hard to create atmosphere and tension. This one just points the camera at a big stone building and hope for the best.
"Some of the historical facts Sharpe throws at us are super random, too."
He mentions the Plains of Abraham but doesn't really explain why they matter to the average viewer, just that they are there. It is like a modern travel TikTok but with zero music and way more static.
The best part of the whole thing is easily the background footage of the old streets. You see these tiny, boxy cars chugging along dirt-adjacent roads. And the people! They all look so incredibly dressed up just to walk down the street to buy some bread. Even the kids are wearing tiny suits. It looks so uncomfortable.
If you like "time machine" style media, this is a fun little diversion. Just do not expect it to change your life or anything.

IMDb —
1918
Community
Log in to comment.