6.2/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 6.2/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Cousin from Nowhere remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you have a soft spot for those old German operettas where everyone seems slightly caffeinated, you'll probably dig The Cousin from Nowhere.
It’s not some deep masterpiece, but it’s perfect if you want to turn your brain off and watch people get confused about who is marrying who. If you hate subtitles or 1930s stagey acting, you should definitely skip this one. 🎬
Lien Deyers plays Julia, and she spends a lot of time looking out windows. She's waiting for her childhood sweetheart, Roderich, who is off in India doing... something.
Her uncle Josua is... a lot. He’s played by Jakob Tiedtke, who has this unbelievable way of puffing out his chest when he's annoyed.
He wants her to marry August, this rich merchant, because money makes everything easier in these movies. It’s a very simple setup, maybe even a bit too simple, but it works for what it is.
The plot really gets moving when a stranger shows up. Everyone just assumes he's the cousin from Batavia (or India, the movie is a bit vague on the geography there).
The way the stranger just rolls with it is hilarious. He doesn't even try to correct them for like, thirty minutes. He just eats their food and hangs out. 🍗
I love the scene where they are all sitting at the table and the tension is just... weirdly thick for a comedy. You can tell they were trying to make it feel important, but it just feels like people being awkward at dinner.
The music is by Eduard Künneke, and it’s actually pretty catchy. You might find yourself humming the "I'm only a poor wandering man" tune later tonight.
It feels a bit like The Merry Jailbirds in how it handles the comedy, though maybe a bit more polite. Some of the singing goes on a bit long, though.
There is one shot where the camera stays on a flower for like ten seconds while someone hits a high note. It’s just... why? 🌸
Rudolf Platte shows up too. He’s always great at playing the guy who looks like he’s perpetually confused by life.
His face is just built for this kind of stuff. He doesn't have to do much, he just stands there and it's funny.
The movie moves fast, which is good because the logic is paper-thin. Like, how do you not recognize your own cousin? I know, I know, it's a "musical thing," but still.
It reminds me a bit of the energy in The Lamb, where the plot is just an excuse for the vibes. The sets look like they were built in a weekend, but they have that cozy, theatrical feel.
It's much more fun than something like Turksib, which is basically a documentary about a railroad. This is just pure fluff. ☁️
One thing that bugged me was the lighting in the garden scene. It’s supposed to be night, but it’s so bright you can see the shadows of the studio equipment.
Or maybe that was a tree? I couldn't tell, the print I watched was a bit grainy. Anyway, if you like Lien Deyers, she’s great here.
She has this very specific way of smiling that makes you think she knows the movie is ridiculous. It’s like she’s in on the joke with the audience.
The ending is exactly what you think it is. No surprises there. But sometimes that’s what you want on a Tuesday night.
I did notice a few weird things though:
It's a nice little time capsule. Not every movie needs to change your life.
Sometimes you just want to see a guy pretend to be someone else while a girl sings about her heart. It’s way better than A Branded Soul, which is just depressing.
Go in with low expectations for the "plot" and you'll have a good time. Just don't expect it to make much sense if you think about it for more than five minutes.
I think I liked the dog in the background of the house scenes more than some of the actors. He seemed like the only one who knew what was actually going on. 🐕
Anyway, it's worth a watch if you can find a decent version of it. It’s short, it’s sweet, and it doesn't overstay its welcome too much.

IMDb 5.7
1927
Community
Log in to comment.