6.5/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 6.5/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Berkeley Square remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Honestly, only if you like movies that feel like a dusty old play. If you need pacing or, you know, stuff happening every five minutes, stay away. But if you’re a sucker for that specific brand of 1930s melancholy where everyone talks in perfect sentences while looking miserable? Yeah, you’ll dig this.
It’s not quite a ghost story, though it feels like one. Leslie Howard is playing that specific type of neurotic, dreamy guy he was so good at. He wanders around the house like he’s lost his keys, but really he’s just trying to find the 1700s again.
The transition scenes are… well, they’re something. There’s a lot of shimmering light and Howard looking like he’s trying to remember if he left the stove on. It’s supposed to be magical, but it’s mostly just him closing his eyes really hard. 🕰️
There’s a part in the middle where the film just stops. It’s not a plot point. He just sits there. The silence lasts just long enough to make you wonder if your internet cut out. I kinda loved that nobody tried to force an explosion or a chase scene in there.
It reminded me a bit of the weird, stilted energy you get in The Queen of Sheba, where everything feels slightly like a museum exhibit that’s come to life. Except, you know, with less gold and more damp British hallways.
Is it perfect? Not even close. The logic of the time travel is basically 'I thought about it really hard.' But there’s something about how Howard holds his teacup that makes you forget how silly the premise is. It’s a strange, quiet little movie. Not for everyone, but definitely for someone.
