5.8/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 5.8/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Manga: Tonpei to sarukichi remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Alright, let’s talk about Manga: Tonpei to sarukichi. Right off the bat, if you’re looking for something with a modern pace or crisp animation, you’re gonna have a bad time. This film, from 1927, is a historical artifact more than it is 'entertainment' by today’s standards. It’s definitely worth a watch if you’re into the *origins* of animation, especially Japanese animation. For animation historians, or just folks curious about how it all started, this is a little treasure. But for everyone else? You’ll probably find it incredibly slow and, well, basic. 😴
It’s directed by Yasuji Murata, who was a big name in early Japanese animation. You can feel his hand in every jerky, enthusiastic frame. This isn't just some random old film; it’s a piece of the puzzle that led to everything we watch today.
The animation here is *so* simple, almost like a moving flipbook. You get these bold, clear lines, and the characters, Tonpei and Sarukichi (a badger-like creature and a monkey), move with a kind of earnest, stop-motion energy. It’s not smooth, not fluid, but it has a certain honest appeal.
There's a scene, or rather, a series of quick cuts, where they’re doing something silly, I think trying to trick each other, and the expressions on their faces are just these quick, exaggerated changes. You can almost feel the animator, Murata-san, figuring out how to convey emotion with just a few lines.
What I found fascinating was just how *much* work went into making these few minutes of moving images. Every single frame drawn by hand. It really makes you appreciate the craft before computers took over.
The whole thing feels very much like a folk tale come to life, which makes sense given the characters. There’s a playful, almost mischievous spirit to their antics. Like, one moment, Sarukichi is just *there*, then suddenly he's doing a little jump. It’s not always clear why, but it’s part of the fun.
Plot-wise, don’t expect a three-act structure. It’s more a series of vignettes, little moments between the two characters. There’s a bit of slapstick, a little bit of chase, and it all unfolds without any dialogue, relying entirely on the visual storytelling. Which, for 1927, was still pretty cutting edge.
You can almost hear the piano score that would have accompanied this in a theater back then. It really makes you think about the *experience* of going to the movies when this was new. What a novelty!
One particular shot, it’s just a close-up on one of the characters’ faces as they react to something off-screen. It lingers just a *touch* too long, and you can see the slight imperfections, the little wobbles in the drawing. But that’s what makes it feel so human, so real.
It’s not trying to be deep or profound. It’s just showing you these characters, doing their thing. And in that simplicity, there’s a quiet charm. It doesn't overstay its welcome. Just gives you a taste of early animated antics.
Ultimately, Manga: Tonpei to sarukichi isn’t a film you ‘enjoy’ in the modern sense of being swept away by a story. It’s a film you *observe*. You look at it, you think about where it came from, and you appreciate the sheer audacity of making moving pictures with such basic tools. It's a little window into the past, and that’s pretty cool. 🕰️

IMDb 6.7
1923
Community
Log in to comment.