6.9/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 6.9/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Mother Pluto remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you have ten minutes and need something that isn't heavy, Mother Pluto is a total win. It’s pure, old-school Disney charm that doesn't overstay its welcome. If you hate cartoons where the animals are just constantly crying or making high-pitched noise, you might want to skip this one. Otherwise, it’s a perfect Saturday morning watch.
Pluto is a great character because he’s always just trying to get through the day without any trouble. Then the universe dumps a dozen chicks on him. Watching him try to maintain his dignity while being treated like a giant, furry mother hen is genuinely funny.
I found myself laughing at the rooster’s entrance. He shows up with all this unnecessary bravado, acting like he’s ready to fight a dog five times his size. It’s such a classic trope, but it’s done with so much personality here.
It’s not quite as slapstick-heavy as something like A Barnyard Cavalier, but it has a warmer heart. Pluto actually gets a win at the end, which is nice. Usually, in these shorts, he gets the short end of the stick. Here, he gets a hug.
The pacing is a bit weird when the hen returns, though. It feels like the writers didn't quite know how to end the conflict, so they just had a quick spat and called it a day. The resolution happens in seconds. One minute there’s a fight, the next minute the chicks are tucked back into the straw and everyone is happy.
It’s fine, though. You don't watch these for the deep narrative structure. You watch them to see Pluto’s eyes go wide when he realizes he's trapped in a doghouse with a dozen tiny birds. 🐥
If you're looking for something with a bit more grit or mystery, maybe look at Phantom Police instead. But if you just want to smile at a dog trying to be a good dad? This is the one.
