7.3/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 7.3/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Roman einer Nacht remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you love dusty, crackling 1930s European cinema where the plot feels like it was written on a napkin during a lunch break, you might actually enjoy Roman einer Nacht. But if you need things like "coherent pacing" or "sensible character choices," please stay far away from this one. 🤷♂️
It is a German movie from 1933 that somehow feels both incredibly frantic and totally asleep.
The basic setup is that the daughter of Copenhagen's police chief is running around France and gets tangled up with a detective.
This detective is supposed to be searching for a "criminal professor," which sounds way cooler than it actually plays out.
The plot make no sense really, but the vibe is what matters here.
Instead of a tense mystery like The Crime of the Hour, we get a lot of people standing in rooms looking slightly confused.
Liane Haid plays the lead with this constant, wide-eyed expression. She looks like she is perpetually trying to remember if she locked her front door.But the real reason I sat through this was to spot Max Schreck.
Yes, the actual guy from Nosferatu is in this, though he is playing a tiny role and looks shockingly normal. It is almost disappointing to see him without the pointy ears, honestly.
The film has these random musical bits that just drop in from nowhere.
One scene has the Kardosch-Sänger group singing, and the camera just stares at them for what feels like five minutes.
You can tell the director was just happy that the technology allowed for sound, so they let the music run way too long. 🎶
The audio quality on the copy I found was pretty rough, like someone was frying bacon right next to the microphone.
It gives the whole thing a cozy, ghostly vibe, though.
It does not have the rustic charm of old silent melodramas like Heart o' the Hills, but it has its own weird energy.
The detective character is a total weirdo.
He does not really do much detecting; he mostly just hangs around looking smug and making grand gestures.
There is this one shot where he lights a cigarette and the match burn is so bright it almost washes out the whole screen.
I doubt anyone made this movie thinking people would be dissecting it nearly a century later.
It is a messy, forgotten piece of cinema that is only worth it for the hardcore archive diggers.

IMDb 6.5
1931
Community
Log in to comment.