DbcultAccessing Vault...
5.1/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 5.1/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Sit Tight remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Okay, so you’re wondering about Sit Tight from 1931. Is it a must-see today? Probably not for everyone, honestly. If you’re really into early sound comedies, or you’re a big Joe E. Brown fan, then yeah, it’s worth a look. Otherwise, you might find it a bit… *quaint*, almost. Definitely not for anyone expecting modern pacing or, you know, super current humor.
The premise is pretty simple, pretty much what you'd guess: Joe E. Brown plays Elmer, this meek office clerk who somehow gets pulled into the world of professional wrestling by two gym managers. They want to turn him into a champion. Classic underdog stuff, right? 🥊
Brown, bless his heart, is all over the place. His signature wide-mouth grin is practically a character in itself. He mugs for the camera constantly, and sometimes it’s really funny, like when he's trying to act tough but clearly has no idea what he's actually doing. It’s **pure physical comedy**.
But other times, it feels like the movie just kinda lets him go off script for minutes. You get these moments where he's just... yelling. Super energetic, no doubt, but sometimes it's a bit much, you know?
Winnie Lightner is in this too, playing the tough-as-nails gym secretary, Sally. She's got some really snappy lines. There’s this one scene where she’s trying to teach Elmer to dance, and her exasperation? It’s pretty great. A good counterpoint to Brown's manic energy, for sure.
The wrestling scenes themselves are exactly what you'd expect from 1931. Lots of staged grappling, flailing, and exaggerated falls. There’s this one bit where Elmer tries a move and accidentally trips himself, and it’s genuinely chuckle-worthy. The sound effects for the hits are pretty basic, but they get the job done.
One thing that stuck with me was Arthur Hoyt as the endlessly flustered gym manager, Mr. Wiggins. He’s always clutching his chest or wringing his hands. His expressions are just priceless, even if he doesn't have a ton of lines. It’s the little things.
The pacing, well, it’s a product of its time. Some scenes feel like they could have been trimmed down quite a bit. There’s a bit in the middle where Elmer is supposedly "training," but it mostly involves him running around looking confused. It goes on a little long, honestly.
And the crowd noise during the big match? It sounds like they recorded about five people and then just looped it a bunch. It really takes you out of the moment, making the "packed arena" feel pretty empty. 🤷♂️ You can almost hear the microphone not quite picking up everything.
The humor is very much slapstick and verbal gags. Some of it lands, some of it definitely doesn't anymore, which is fine. There’s a running gag about Elmer accidentally breaking things, which is simple, but it gets a few smiles.
I also kept noticing the costumes. Elmer starts in this ridiculously ill-fitting suit, then transitions to these wrestling tights that look about three sizes too big. It adds to his awkward charm, though I really wonder if that was fully intentional or just how things fit back then, you know?
The plot itself isn't exactly groundbreaking. It's a formula, sure. But it’s the little moments, like when Elmer tries to flirt and just ends up stumbling over his words, that make it feel human. He's not some polished hero. He's just... Elmer. A real goofball.
There's a scene near the end where the villains are trying to sabotage Elmer’s big fight. It’s all very cartoonish. One guy tries to trip him, another tries to hit him with a chair. It’s less about suspense and more about the sheer absurdity of it all. Like, come on guys. 😅
For a movie made when sound was still pretty new, it does a decent job. The dialogue is mostly clear, even if the acting style is pretty big and theatrical. You can feel them still figuring things out, learning the ropes with the mics and all.
So, should you carve out an hour and change for Sit Tight? If you're looking for a breezy, old-school comedy and appreciate the early days of talkies, then absolutely. It's got its charms, mostly thanks to Joe E. Brown’s boundless energy and Winnie Lightner’s sharp wit. Just don’t expect any deep insights into the human condition or anything. It’s just a guy trying not to get slammed in a wrestling ring. And sometimes, that’s totally enough. 😄
IMDb —
1919
Community
Log in to comment.
