6.1/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 6.1/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Aviator remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Alright, so we’re talking about The Aviator from 1929. Is this one worth digging up today? Well, if you have a soft spot for really early talkies and the particular brand of neurotic comedy Edward Everett Horton perfected, then yes, absolutely. You’ll find some real charm here. But if you're used to modern pacing or slick visuals, you might be scratching your head. This isn't for everyone, and it definitely won’t win over someone expecting, like, explosions or anything. 😂
Horton plays a playwright, Robert Street, who’s just terribly shy. He writes these adventure stories, see, but can barely order a cup of coffee without getting all flustered. And then, through some truly convoluted circumstances – the kind only a 1929 comedy could dream up – he ends up famous. Not for his writing, but for being a daring aviator! A hero, even. The whole thing’s a delightful mess from the start.
The whole premise of a timid man pretending to be a hero is classic. Horton just nails it. Every twitch, every stammer, every wide-eyed look of panic. He’s simply **the best** at that specific kind of anxious comedy. You just watch him trying to keep this whole charade going, and you can practically feel his blood pressure rising. It’s glorious.
One scene sticks with me where he’s at a fancy party, surrounded by people praising his supposed flying feats. He just keeps trying to deflect, making vague noises and looking desperately for an exit. The camera lingers on his face, and you just see this man melting inside. It’s less about the dialogue there and more about Horton’s physical comedy. He doesn't say much, but you get it.
Of course, the big problem is that eventually, he’s expected to actually *fly*. This is where the movie gets really silly, in the best possible way. The solutions they come up with to keep him out of a cockpit are just pure old-school farce. There's a bit where he's supposed to take off, and the whole crew is just doing their darndest to keep the plane grounded without making it look obvious. It's like watching a bunch of kids trying to pull off a prank, only with much higher stakes.
The special effects, if you can even call them that, are pretty rudimentary. When you see the plane in the air, it's clearly a model or a very obvious stage set. But honestly, that’s part of the charm. It adds to the film's innocent, playful vibe. You're not supposed to believe it’s real for a second; you’re just supposed to enjoy the ridiculousness of it all. It’s almost **meta** in how it embraces its own phoniness. 🤔
Patsy Ruth Miller is in it too, as the love interest. She's fine, playing the straight man to Horton’s escalating panic. She looks nice. But honestly, she’s mostly there to react to Horton’s antics and provide a reason for him to keep up the pretense. Her character doesn’t get a whole lot of depth, but then again, this isn't that kind of movie. It's about the central gag.
What’s interesting is how quickly the movie moves. It feels like a stage play sometimes, with people rushing in and out, doors slamming, and misunderstandings piling up. The dialogue is snappy, even for 1929. They clearly knew how to write a good setup and punchline back then. It's not a slow burn at all. The entire thing feels like it’s in a constant, delightful hurry.
You can tell it was still early days for sound film. Sometimes the audio feels a bit flat, or the background noise is a tad inconsistent. But it rarely pulls you out of the story. You just adjust to it. It’s a snapshot of a moment in cinema history, really.
I found myself smiling throughout most of this. It’s not a film that tries to be profound or make a grand statement. It just wants to entertain with some good, clean, old-fashioned absurdity. And in that, it definitely succeeds. It’s a little gem for those who appreciate the quirks of early cinema. A fun afternoon watch, if you know what you’re getting into. 🎬

IMDb 6.8
1923
Community
Log in to comment.