5.7/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 5.7/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Black Coin remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Honestly, only if you’ve got a weird soft spot for grainy, low-budget stuff where people spend half the runtime pointing guns at each other in alleyways. If you need logic or, you know, acting that doesn't feel like a high school play, you’re gonna hate it. It’s cheap, it’s loud, and it barely hangs together.
There is this moment where the federal agents corner the smugglers, but the blocking makes it look like they’re just standing in a very small sandbox together. It’s bizarre. Nobody seems to know where to stand.
The whole thing feels like it was filmed in a basement with the lights turned up way too high. There are secret papers involved, obviously. They’re treated like the holy grail, even though half the time the characters seem to forget who has them.
I found myself staring at a wall in the background of one scene for, like, three minutes. The plaster was peeling in such a specific way that it was more interesting than the dialogue. Speaking of, the dialogue is pure filler. It’s just people shouting about where the coin is or who shot who.
It’s a bit like watching Up in the Air if it had been stripped of every single cent of its budget and handed to a group of people who had never actually seen a spy movie. There's a certain charm to the desperation, I guess.
You can tell the director was just trying to get the cameras to stop rolling so they could all go home. There’s no flair. Just movement. Just guys in hats running into rooms and running out again. 🎩
If you’ve seen Money for Speed, you’ll recognize that specific, slightly frantic energy that happens when a film crew knows they’re making something that’s going to be buried by time. It’s not necessarily bad, just... very, very small.
Sometimes the sound cuts out for a split second, and I’m not sure if it was my connection or if the movie just decided to take a breath. I didn't mind the silence. It was better than the shouting.
Don't expect to remember the ending. I think I watched it twice and I'm still not entirely sure how the papers were settled. Just treat it like background noise for a rainy afternoon. Or don't. It probably won't change your life either way. 🤷♂️

IMDb —
1923
Community
Log in to comment.