7/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 7/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Eagle and the Hawk remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you like your war movies with a heavy side of existential dread rather than just flag-waving, then yeah, put this on. It’s not for people who need their heroes to be shiny and perfect. If you prefer the glossy, painless heroics of something like Our Baseball Match, you’ll probably find this way too depressing. It’s definitely not a popcorn flick.
The flying sequences are pretty wild for their time, even if the models occasionally look like they're being held up by fishing line. It’s the faces, though. The movie spends a lot of time just watching guys fall apart after they land.
Fredric March is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. You can see him trying to hold it together while everything around him turns to mud and engine grease. There’s a scene in the mess hall where the lighting is just… aggressive. It makes everyone look like they’re already ghosts.
Cary Grant shows up too, and he’s not the charming guy you’re used to seeing in later years. He’s sharp, a bit mean, and clearly tired of the whole business. It’s a nice change of pace. He doesn't even try to soften the edges. 🛩️
There’s this weird, frantic energy to the editing. Sometimes it cuts away right when you’re starting to care about what someone is saying. It’s frustrating, but it also kind of works because it feels like the characters don't have time to process their own feelings either. They’re too busy dying.
I wouldn't say it’s a masterpiece. It feels a bit clunky in the middle, almost like the film itself is running out of fuel. It lacks the polish you get in something like Hunted People, but it’s got a weird, jagged pulse that I kind of respect.
Maybe it’s just me, but the scene where they’re just sitting around smoking, staring at the ceiling… that felt more real than the actual combat. You can smell the stale tobacco and the fear. It’s not elegant. It’s just sad. 🥃
Don't go in expecting a history lesson. It’s more about the specific, miserable way men handle being told to fly into a meat grinder. It’s messy, a bit uneven, and sticks with you longer than it has any right to.

IMDb —
1923
Community
Log in to comment.