DbcultAccessing Vault...
Cult Review
Senior Film Conservator
If you like watching a man who seemingly has no bones in his body perform stunts, then yes, absolutely. If you want a deep story about the human psyche or something, maybe go watch The Denial instead.
This movie is for people who enjoy 1920s energy and don't mind a plot that feels like it was written on the back of a napkin. I personally think it's a blast, even if it makes very little sense at times.
Richard Talmadge is the star here, and he plays two brothers. One is a rich guy who probably spends too much on tea, and the other is a criminal who just escaped from the law.
The convict brother decides to take over the rich brother's life. It is the oldest trick in the book, really.
I noticed early on that the "evil" twin doesn't really look that different. Usually, they give the bad one a goatee or a menacing hat, but here you just have to keep track based on how much he's scowling.
The movie really gets moving when the stunts start. Talmadge wasn't just an actor; he was basically a circus performer who happened to be on film.
There is this one scene where he climbs up the side of a building that made my knees ache just watching it. He moves with this weird, jittery grace that you don't see in modern movies anymore.
Modern action, like what you see in The Raid, is all about the impact and the bone-crunching sound. This is more about the spectacle of movement.
The pacing is a bit all over the place, honestly. One minute we are in a slow living room scene, and the next, everyone is sprinting across rooftops for no clear reason.
I think the director, Henry Lehrman, just wanted to see how many things Talmadge could jump over in sixty minutes. I am not complaining, though.
There is a specific moment where the brothers finally meet, and the camera trickery is... okay for the time. You can kind of see the fuzzy line in the middle of the screen where they stitched the two shots together.
It’s charming in a way. It reminds you that real people were standing there, trying to figure out how to make magic with big, clunky wooden cameras.
Constance Howard is there too, playing the love interest. She doesn't have much to do besides look alarmed or relieved, depending on which brother she's talking to.
I felt bad for her character. Imagine your boyfriend gets replaced by a criminal and you don't notice because he's just slightly more athletic now.
The middle of the film drags a little bit when they try to explain the legal stuff. No one goes to a Richard Talmadge movie to hear about inheritance laws or court orders.
It’s like when you watch Roaring Rails and you just want to see the train go fast. Just get back to the climbing and the falling, please.
Eventually, the movie remembers it’s an action flick and gives us a grand finale. The fight scenes are very "theatrical," meaning lots of wide swings and people falling over barrels.
I love how they use the furniture. Every chair in this movie is just a stepping stone for a backflip.
One reaction shot of a butler goes on for way too long. He just stares at the camera with this blank, haunting expression while the world falls apart behind him.
It made me laugh out loud, though I don't think it was supposed to be funny. Or maybe it was? Silent humor is hard to judge sometimes.
If you've seen things like The Price of Pleasure, you know that these movies often rely on a very specific kind of melodrama. This one leans more into the physical comedy side of things.
The writing by Rex Taylor is pretty standard stuff. It’s the kind of script that says "Then they fight" and lets the actors do the heavy lifting.
I do wish the ending had a bit more punch to it. It kind of just... stops once the bad guy is caught.
There isn't a big emotional wrap-up. They just sort of dust off their suits and the credits roll.
It’s very much a "get in, do some flips, get out" kind of experience. I respect that level of efficiency in filmmaking.
You can tell this was made for a crowd that just wanted to be entertained on a Saturday afternoon. It doesn't have the heavy atmosphere of something like Im Zeichen der Schuld.
Is it a masterpiece? No way. But it’s a great example of why people loved the silent era stars.
They didn't need CGI or massive budgets. They just needed a guy who was willing to risk his neck for a good shot.
I’ll probably forget the plot of this movie by next week. But I will definitely remember that one jump from the balcony to the chandelier.
That is the kind of thing that sticks with you. Even if the rest of the movie is just okay, that one moment makes the whole thing feel special.
If you have an hour to kill and want to see some old-school hustle, give it a look. Just don't expect it to change your life or anything. 📽️
It’s much better than some of the other stuff from that year, like maybe Whoozit. At least this one has energy.
Anyway, that's my take. Go watch it for the jumps, stay for the weird butler face. 🏃♂️💨
IMDb —
1921
Community
Log in to comment.
