Summary
A gas-lamp flickers above cobblestones slick with moral grime as criminologist Marcel Levington—top-hatted, mind humming like a dynamo of rational inquiry—is accosted by a frantic sylph in torn lace who pleads for a physician to save a man hemorrhaging inside a brothel’s velvet maw. Within minutes Marcel and his confidant Dr. Rogers step through damask-draped corridors reeking of perfume and dread, only to confront a corpse: a celebrated barrister prone on a chaise, heart skewered by a hatpin whose ruby head glints with accusatory familiarity. Rogers recognizes the ornament at once—he gifted it days earlier to his pianist daughter Toinette, a bright chord now turned lethal note. Publicly he declares cardiac collapse; privately he demands confession. Toinette’s trembling account unfurls like a bruise: lured under pretense of patronage, imprisoned in a silk-lined cell, she drove the slender spike through tailored worsted rather than surrender her name. Father and sleuth become co-conspirators in chiaroscuro ethics, erasing evidence, rewriting autopsy ink. Their pact intensifies when Mrs. Clifton, the bordello’s sphinx-eyed proprietress, brandishes Toinette’s forgotten pocketbook like a loaded pistol of blackmail. Marcel, besotted yet calculating, re-enters the den, parries extortion with counter-insinuation, and reclaims the incriminating keepsake. He emerges into pre-dawn fog clutching both leather purse and trembling girl, their silhouettes merging into one fugitive shadow against the first bruised light—a tableau equal parts salvation and damnation.
Synopsis
A young woman, disheveled and greatly distressed, stops criminologist Marcel Levington on the street and begs him to find a doctor for a man who is dying inside a nearby house of ill repute. Marcel and his friend, Dr. Rogers, enter the house and find the man, a prominent lawyer, dead, his heart pierced by a hatpin that the doctor recognizes as the one he recently gave his daughter Toinette. Rogers announces that the man has died of heart failure, returns home and demands an explanation from his daughter, who explains that she was lured into the house and attacked by the man. Realizing that Toinette killed the lawyer to defend her honor, Rogers and Marcel agree to protect her. Marcel retrieves Toinette's pocketbook from the proprietor of the house, Mrs. Clifton, who had planned to blackmail the girl, and then returns to Toinette, with whom he has fallen in love.
Review Excerpt
"
If celluloid could exude opium, The House of Silence would leave viewers woozy, pupils pinned like the very hatpin that skewers a lawyer’s ambition in a velvet-upholstered bordello. Released in March 1917 by Paramount’s San Francisco unit and now languishing in a state of near-fossilized obscurity, this six-reel morality play is less a whodunit than a who-covers-it-up, a narrative inversion that feels startlingly modern in an era when most silent heroines wilted atop railroad tracks.
Director ..."
