7.2/10
Archivist John
Senior Editor

A definitive 7.2/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Behind the Counter remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Honestly, you should watch this if you have an hour to kill and like old-school slapstick that isn't too violent or loud. If you need a deep plot or 4K visuals, you’re gonna hate it. 🍿
I watched this on a Tuesday afternoon while eating cold toast, and it was exactly what my brain needed. Edward Everett Horton has a face that looks like a crumpled paper bag that’s trying to be polite.
He plays a clerk, obviously, and he spends half the movie looking like he’s about to have a heart attack because a customer asked for a different shade of ribbon. It’s not as polished as something like The Strong Man, but it has a weird charm that I can't quite explain.
There is this one bit where a guy in a top hat keeps leaning on the counter and it almost breaks. I don't know why, but I laughed way too hard at that specifically.
The lady playing the love interest, Dorothy Dwan, is here too. She’s looking very 1920s with that specific hair that looks like it’s glued to her head in a permanent wave.
She’s fine, I guess, but she doesn’t have much to do other than look pretty and be the reward for the hero at the end. The sets look like they were built in about twenty minutes using leftover wood from a barn and some cheap paint.
You can see the shadows of the cameras sometimes if you look really closely at the floor. It reminds me a bit of It's the Old Army Game in terms of that small town chaos energy where everyone is annoyed.
There's a scene with a dog that is clearly bored out of its mind. The dog just sits there while Edward is panicking, and it’s honestly the best performance in the whole movie.
I think Nigel Barrie is supposed to be the serious guy, but his mustache is so distracting. It looks like two caterpillars having a fight on his upper lip and its hard to focus on what he is saying... well, showing on the cards.
The pacing is a bit weird, like they forgot to edit some parts. It speeds up for no reason, then slows down while a character reads a letter for like... two minutes straight.
We get it, the letter is bad news, move on already! Some of the jokes are definitely of their time, which is a polite way of saying they don't make sense anymore.
Why is a bucket of flour funny? I don't know, but back then, it was peak comedy for these guys.
If you've seen A Truthful Liar, you know how these things go. It’s a lot of pointing and wide-eyed staring at things that aren't actually that scary.
I liked the ending though, even if it was predictable as heck. It’s the kind of movie you put on when it’s raining and you want to feel like life was simpler when people just tripped over things for a living.
There's a moment where a customer tries on about fifty hats. Every single hat is uglier than the last one, and the look on Horton's face gets more depressed each time.
I felt that in my soul. Working retail hasn't changed in a hundred years, apparently. 👒
The lighting is super harsh too. Everyone looks like they are standing inside a giant lightbulb, but that's just how they did it back then.
I noticed one of the extras in the background was just staring directly at the camera for a solid five seconds. He looked like he was wondering if he left his stove on at home.
It’s little things like that that make these old films feel real to me. It's messy and imperfect and it doesn't care about your grammer or your high standards.
If you enjoy Clara Cleans Her Teeth, you might find this one a bit more professional, but only slightly. It still feels like a bunch of friends got together and decided to mess around in a department store after hours.
I did find myself checking my phone once or twice during the middle bit. The plot kind of wanders off to look at a display of socks for too long.
But then Horton does that little jumpy thing with his feet and you're back in it. He really was a master of being uncomfortable.
The music on the copy I watched was this tinkly piano that sounded like it was being played in another room. It added to the vibe of being in a dusty museum, but in a good way.
Don't expect a masterpiece. It's just a guy, a counter, and a lot of anxiety.
It’s better than Jazz Mad if you prefer comedy over heavy drama. I’ll probably forget most of it by next week, but I’m glad I saw it today.
Sometimes you just need to see a man get defeated by a stack of boxes. It makes my own problems feel a bit smaller, you know?
Anyway, go watch it if you can find a copy that isn't too grainy. Or even if it is grainy, it just adds to the flavor of the whole thing. 🎞️

IMDb 8
1925
Community
Log in to comment.