Cult Review
Senior Film Conservator

Look, if you are the type of person who needs a movie to explode in the first five minutes, just skip Dios y ley. It is not for you. You will be bored out of your mind within ten minutes of the opening credits.
But if you like old, dusty movies that feel like they were filmed in a different universe, this is a really interesting find. It is a movie for people who like to look at faces and landscapes more than they care about a fast plot.
Guillermo Calles basically did everything here. He wrote it, directed it, and he is right there in the middle of the acting too.
The whole thing feels very personal, like he was trying to prove something about the rural life he was filming. It is not polished at all. The camera shakes a little sometimes and the lighting is, well, let us just say it is very natural.
There is this one scene near a well where the characters are just talking about nothing important for way too long. In a modern movie, a producer would have cut that in half. But here, you just sit with them in the heat.
You can almost smell the dirt and the dry air. It has that same lonely feeling you get when watching The Vanishing Pioneer, even though the stories are totally different.
The actress Carmen Guerrero has these eyes that just burn through the grainy film. She does not even have to say much. She just looks at the men and you know exactly what she is thinking about their stupid rules.
The plot is about God and the Law, hence the title. It sounds heavy and academic, but it is actually just about people being stubborn. It is about how the rules made in a city somewhere do not always make sense when you are standing in a desert.
I noticed a weird thing with the editing in the middle of the movie. A character walks out of a room and then, in the next shot, they are already across a field. It is like a whole chunk of time just vanished.
Maybe the film was damaged, or maybe Calles just did not care about the transition. Honestly, it kind of works because it makes the whole thing feel like a dream or a half-remembered story.
Juan Martinez plays his role pretty straight, but Joe Dominguez brings a bit of extra energy that the movie really needs. Some of the other actors look like they were just people Calles found on the street that morning. They keep looking at the camera like they are confused.
It is not a perfect film by any means. The sound—if you can even call it that in these old versions—is crackly and thin. You have to really squint to see what is happening during the night scenes.
But there is a raw honesty here. It reminds me of the simple, direct way stories were told in Roads of Destiny. No flashy tricks, just people and their problems.
I found myself thinking about the church scenes for a long time after it ended. The way the shadows fall across the floor is just beautiful in a way that feels accidental. Like the sun just happened to be in the right place and they hit record.
Is it a masterpiece? Probably not. It is a bit messy and the ending feels like it happens because they ran out of film rather than because the story was over.
But it is a real movie. It does not feel like it was made by a committee or a machine. It feels like one man’s very loud opinion about his country.
If you have seen The Guilty Man, you might recognize some of that same heavy atmosphere. That feeling that no matter what you do, the world is going to crush you anyway.
I liked it, even when I was frustrated by how slow it was. It made me want to go sit in the sun and think about nothing for an hour.
The kids will hate it. Your friend who only watches blockbusters will hate it. But if you want to see where Mexican cinema really started to find its own voice, you should probably find a copy. 🌵
Just do not expect a happy ending or a clean resolution. That is not what this kind of movie is for. It is just a slice of a life that does not exist anymore.

IMDb —
1917
Community
Log in to comment.