DbcultAccessing Vault...
5.6/10
Archivist John
Senior Editor
A definitive 5.6/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Earl Burtnett and His Biltmore Hotel Orchestra remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you have ten minutes and a weird obsession with the way people used to stand in 1928, this is probably for you. It is a Vitaphone short, which means it is basically a time machine that only goes to the Biltmore Hotel.
Most people will find this incredibly boring. There is no story, no acting, just Earl and his guys playing music while looking slightly terrified of the microphone.
The first song is 'I Fell Head Over Heels in Love' and it is exactly as peppy as you would expect. The rhythm is very stiff, almost like they are afraid if they move too much, the whole camera will explode.
I noticed one of the sax players has this look on his face like he forgot to turn the stove off at home. He is staring into the middle distance while his fingers do the work. It is these little human moments that make these old shorts worth it, honestly.
The lighting is very flat. It makes everyone look like they are made of wax, which adds to the ghostly vibe of the whole thing. It is not exactly a high-budget affair like The Misleading Lady, but it has its own charm.
Earl Burtnett himself is quite the character. He conducts with these tiny, precise movements. You can tell he really ran a tight ship at the Biltmore.
The second song, 'An Old Guitar and an Old Refrain', slows things down a bit. It is a little too sentimental for me, if I am being honest. The guitar work is fine, but the audio quality makes it sound like it is being played from the bottom of a well.
You can hear the hiss of the wax disc underneath the melody. Some people hate that noise, but I kind of love it. It reminds you that this was recorded almost a hundred years ago.
It is wild to think about how modern this must have felt at the time. To see a band and hear them at the same time was a miracle back then. Now, it is just something we scroll past on YouTube.
I found myself looking at the background more than the band. The drapes look heavy and dusty. I bet that room smelled like stale tobacco and expensive perfume.
Compared to something like Cardigan, this feels much more grounded in reality because it is just a recording of a performance. There is no artifice here, just the hustle of a working band.
'Blue River' is the final track and it is easily the best one. It has a bit more soul to it. The brass section finally wakes up and gives it some punch.
There is a moment where the camera lingers on a guy playing the banjo. He is really leaning into it. He is the only one who looks like he is actually having fun instead of just doing a job.
The short ends abruptly, which is typical for these things. No credits, no goodbye, just a fade to black. It leaves you feeling a bit empty, like the party ended and you were the last one to leave.
If you are looking for a deep cinematic experience like Man and Maid, you are in the wrong place. This is just a slice of life from a hotel lobby that doesn't exist anymore.
I think it is worth a watch just to see the suits. They don't make lapels like that anymore. 🎷
The way the sound cuts out right at the end is a bit jarring. It makes you realize how fragile these old films are. One scratch and the whole thing is gone.
Is it a masterpiece? No. Is it a fascinating look at the birth of the talkies? Absolutely. Just don't expect it to change your life.
Community
Log in to comment.
