DbcultAccessing Vault...
Cult Review
Archivist John
Senior Editor
Is this film worth watching? Short answer: Yes, but it’s more than a mere curiosity; it’s a well-crafted exploration of 1930s social dynamics, filled with memorable performances and a complex plot. This film is for those who enjoy period pieces with a bit of grit and a dash of scandal. It’s not for the faint of heart, as it contains a darker undercurrent that may be too much for some.
The performances in 'Good and Naughty' are standout features that drive the narrative. Warner Richmond delivers a nuanced portrayal of Gerald Gray, a man torn between his affection for Germaine and his affair with Claire. Pola Negri, as Germaine, brings a striking presence and a mix of vulnerability and strength, making her character relatable despite her flaws. The supporting cast, including Marie Mosquini and Stuart Holmes, adds depth to the story, each bringing their own unique charms and conflicts.
The pacing can be uneven at times, with some scenes dragging on more than necessary. The film’s reliance on plot twists and misunderstandings occasionally feels contrived. Additionally, the film’s ending, while satisfying in its own way, is somewhat predictable, leaving less room for surprise or lingering intrigue.
You're a fan of period dramas with a touch of danger and intrigue. If you appreciate films that challenge gender roles and social norms of the 1930s, 'Good and Naughty' is a must-watch. It’s also a great choice for those who are intrigued by the complexities of love, infidelity, and the power of disguise.
Germaine Morris, a plain-looking woman, is in love with her employer, Gerald Gray, an interior decorator. Her affections are not reciprocated, but she remains loyal and hopeful. Claire Fenton, a wealthy broker’s wife and Gerald’s mistress, is threatened by Germaine’s increasing presence. To protect her marriage and her affair, Claire invites Gerald on a yachting trip to Florida, where she plans to use her friend Bunny West’s showgirl, Chouchou Rouselle, as a decoy. However, Germaine cleverly convinces Gerald to let her pose as his fiancée instead. In Florida, Germaine’s beauty captivates everyone, including Gerald. Her success with the men on the yacht causes a rift between Claire and Gerald. The situation becomes more complex when Smith, a showgirl’s admirer, tries to claim Chouchou, leading to a physical confrontation.
Is 'Good and Naughty' worth your time? Absolutely, but it requires an open mind and a willingness to engage with a darker, more complex story than what you might find in modern films.
'Good and Naughty' is a film that challenges expectations and offers a fresh perspective on a classic love triangle story. Despite its flaws, it is a well-crafted exploration of 1930s social dynamics, filled with memorable performances and a complex plot. It’s a film that requires an open mind and a willingness to engage with a darker, more complex story than what you might find in modern films.
While 'Good and Naughty' is not without its flaws, it is a well-crafted exploration of 1930s social dynamics, filled with memorable performances and a complex plot. It’s a film that challenges expectations and offers a fresh perspective on a classic love triangle story. If you’re willing to engage with a darker, more complex story than what you might find in modern films, then 'Good and Naughty' is definitely worth your time.
IMDb —
1925
Community
Log in to comment.
