DbcultAccessing Vault...
5.7/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 5.7/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Harmony Heaven remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
You should probably watch Harmony Heaven if you have a soft spot for grainy films where everyone sounds like they are auditioning for a play. If you want fast action or a plot that moves quickly, you should skip this one immediately.
It is a very slow movie. It feels like it was filmed in a library where everyone is afraid to wake up the neighbors.
The story is about a composer named Bill who wants to be famous. He has a girlfriend who is very nice, but then a fancy lady comes along and things get messy.
The fancy lady wants him for herself. Or maybe she just wants to be near someone with talent.
It is hard to tell because the acting is a bit wooden. It reminded me of Iris but with more singing and less drama.
Bill Shine plays the lead, and he looks constantly worried. He spends a lot of time sitting at a piano looking at sheet music like it is a math problem he cannot solve.
There is a scene where he is trying to write a song and the girl is helping him. It is supposed to be romantic, but it feels like two people trying to assemble furniture without the instructions.
Then we get the socialite. Her name is Lady Violet or something equally fancy, and she wears these massive hats.
I spent about ten minutes just wondering how she kept her head upright. The hat is basically its own character in the movie.
She flirts with Bill by leaning against things. Every piece of furniture in her house gets leaned on at some point.
The songs are... okay. They are the kind of tunes that you forget the second the scene ends.
The sound quality is pretty rough too. It sounds like the actors are talking through a thick wool blanket.
I think this was one of the first British movies with color, but the version I saw was mostly grey and dusty. You can almost smell the old film reels through the screen.
There is a dance number that goes on way too long. The dancers look like they are trying very hard not to trip over each other.
It’s not as exciting as The Three Musketeers, that is for sure. It feels much smaller and more contained.
I noticed that the sets look very thin. If someone slammed a door too hard, the whole room would probably fall over.
It has that strange 1930s energy where everyone stands perfectly still while they talk. It’s like they are afraid the microphone won't catch them if they move an inch.
The movie wraps up exactly how you think it will. There are no big twists or surprises here.
It is a simple story about a guy choosing between fame and the girl who actually likes him. We have seen this a million times, but it is interesting to see how they did it 90 years ago.
If you like The Jungle or maybe Desert Valley, you might find this charming in a weird way. It is a time capsule more than a movie.
I don't think I would watch it again. Once was enough to get the idea.
The way the composer finally gets his big break is a bit silly. It happens so fast you might miss it if you blink.
Overall, it’s a fine way to spend an hour if you are bored and like old stuff. Just don't expect it to change your life.
Why is the lighting so dark in the hallway? I couldn't see who was talking for a minute. The girl, Joan, has a very high-pitched voice that made my dog tilt his head.
I think I saw a shadow of a microphone at the top of the screen around the 40-minute mark. Or maybe it was just a very dark cloud in the set design.
The movie gets slightly better when the socialite is on screen because she is so over-the-top. She acts like she is in a completely different, much more exciting film.
Bill Shine is okay, but he lacks that spark. He just seems like a nice guy who got lost on his way to a grocery store.
If you’re into the history of early sound films, check it out. Otherwise, go watch something with more than three sets.
IMDb 6.9
1922
Community
Log in to comment.
