4.9/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 4.9/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Hill-Tillies remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Alright, so Hill-Tillies isn't going to redefine cinema, not by a long shot. But if you're a real film history buff, or maybe just curious about what Inflation-era short films felt like, then yeah, give it a whirl. Anyone looking for a coherent plot or, you know, _modern_ comedy, will probably be pulling their hair out. 😵💫
The whole thing kicks off with these two girls, clearly meant to be a bit glamorous, heading out to the woods for a publicity stunt. The idea itself is so perfectly 1930s. Like, 'Let's get lost for fame!' What could go wrong?
And, surprise, they get lost. The 'woods' look suspiciously like a backlot set, but you gotta appreciate the effort. The girls' reactions swing from mildly annoyed to cartoonishly panicked, which is exactly what you’d expect.
Then enters the agent, a man of *many* hand gestures, who frets around like a chicken with its head cut off. He decides the best course of action is to send a couple of 'Indian scouts' to find them. This is where things get… well, _of its time_.
One of these scouts is played by none other than Jim Thorpe, the actual Olympic legend. It's a small part, mostly stoic, but seeing him there is just this weird, fascinating little detail. He just kinda… *is* there. You almost wish they gave him more to do than just tracking.
Patsy Kelly, though, she's the real standout. She's got this _energy_. Her line delivery, even when it's just a quick quip, lands with a certain *oomph*. You can tell she's just having a blast with the material, even if the material itself is pretty thin. Lyda Roberti, too, brings a similar kind of zany charm. They carry a lot of the comedic heavy lifting.
The pacing is… frantic at times, then suddenly slows down for what feels like an eternity while someone tries to untangle a rope. It's not a smooth ride. Some scenes go on a beat too long, and others feel cut way too short, like they ran out of film or patience. 🎬
There's a moment where one of the girls tries to start a fire with two sticks, and it's just so *bad* at it, you almost feel a little sorry for her. The sound effects for the 'wild animals' are clearly just someone making noises backstage. It's all part of the charm, I suppose.
The 'rescue' itself is pretty anti-climactic. They just sort of… find them. No big heroics, just a lot of relieved shouting and, of course, more hand gestures from the agent. It leaves you wondering what the *actual* publicity stunt was supposed to achieve, beyond proving these two shouldn't go camping.
This film is less about a story and more about a vibe. A slightly chaotic, genuinely old-school comedic vibe. It's a curiosity, a little peek into a simpler (and sometimes weirder) time in filmmaking. Not a masterpiece, but definitely not boring if you know what you're getting into. 👍

IMDb —
1918
Community
Log in to comment.