DbcultAccessing Vault...
6.2/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 6.2/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Idle Chatter remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Okay, so "Idle Chatter" is definitely *not* for everyone. If you’re looking for a traditional narrative, or even just something that makes immediate sense, you'll probably hate it.
But if you’re into utterly strange, almost surreal short films that just *exist*, then yeah, you gotta see this. It's a real head-scratcher, in the best way possible.
It’s basically just Lou Holtz. Like, *the* Lou Holtz. He's sitting there, looking straight into the camera. And he starts talking about ballet. 🩰
He seems genuinely into it, which is the first surprise. He mentions how the girls are always running, but no one's chasing them.
And the men are always running *to* the women. This isn't groundbreaking stuff, but coming from him, it just lands differently.
Then, things take a turn. He segues, quite smoothly actually, into nursery rhymes. Not just one, but a mashup.
"Little Miss Muffet sat on a tuffet," then suddenly it's about "Baa Baa Black Sheep," and maybe a bit of "Jack and Jill." It's a complete, long dissertation of these lines, all blended together.
You just sit there, kinda dumbfounded, watching this man deliver these lines with such earnestness. He’s not laughing, he’s not winking. He’s just *doing it*.
It feels like a moment caught out of time. There’s this one part where he pauses, just for a beat, after a particularly jumbled rhyme.
He just looks at the camera, and you can almost feel the gears turning in his head, or maybe just the *absence* of gears. It’s hard to tell if he’s improvising or reciting a carefully constructed, bizarre script.
The whole thing feels like a recording of a very specific, slightly unhinged stream of consciousness. It's oddly compelling.
You don't know *why* he's saying these things, or *who* he's saying them to. The lack of context is part of its charm.
It’s less a film and more an encounter. Like you stumbled into a strange living room and Lou Holtz decided to share his latest thoughts with you.
And those thoughts happen to be about ballet and nursery rhymes. I kept waiting for a punchline, or some kind of reveal. But it never really comes.
It just... *is*. And then it ends. The abruptness is almost as jarring as the content itself.
You might find yourself replaying certain lines. Like, "why *are* the girls always running with no one chasing them?" He’s got a point there, actually. 🤔
Is it a comedy? A performance art piece? A lost moment of genius? Honestly, it’s all of them and none of them.
It's just Lou Holtz, sharing some Idle Chatter. And it's strangely unforgettable. It really sticks with you, this little oddity.
The camera work is super simple. Just him, a plain background. No fancy cuts, no dramatic lighting.
It's all about his presence and the sheer unexpectedness of his words. It feels like a home video that accidentally captured something profoundly weird.
You know, it reminded me a bit of some of those really early TV experiments, like The First Television Picture with a Greyscale Image, not in content, but in its raw, unfiltered presentation.
Just someone, *being*, on screen. No frills. It’s just fascinating to see such a public figure in such an utterly uncharacteristic setting.
You go in expecting *something*, and you get something else entirely. Something much weirder.
I actually chuckled out loud a few times, not because it was "funny" in a traditional sense, but because of the sheer audacity of it. The lack of explanation. The commitment.
It’s a very *human* kind of oddness. It felt like a very long thought, condensed into a short film. A single, meandering thought that someone just decided to film. And I'm kinda glad they did.
IMDb 6.9
1926
Community
Log in to comment.
