6.2/10
Archivist John
Senior Editor

A definitive 6.2/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Momotaro the Undefeated remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Okay, so Momotaro the Undefeated isn't exactly a blockbuster you'd queue up for, not today anyway. If you're into the really old stuff, like, early animation or just curious about how these classic tales got told on screen way back when, then yeah, give it a look. Everyone else, probably gonna find it a bit... slow, maybe even boring, really.
The whole thing starts just how you'd expect, right? An old couple, can't have kids, and then — bam! — a giant peach bobs down the river. Finding a baby inside.
What struck me first was the feeling of it all. It’s so unpretentious. The animation, credited to Sanae Yamamoto, it’s not flashy, obviously. But it has this Ramshackle House kind of earnestness, you know?
The scenes of Momotaro growing up are super quick. One minute he’s a baby, the next he's like, a strapping young lad, ready for adventure. There's not much dilly-dallying there.
I found myself smiling at the way his animal companions join him. The dog, the monkey, the pheasant. Each one has this brief, almost comical moment of agreeing to come along. It’s very much like, “Sure, why not? Let’s fight some demons.”
The demon island, it’s not some terrifying, gothic place. It's more like a slightly mischievous, slightly dangerous vacation spot. The demons themselves are kinda goofy looking, actually.
There's this one shot of Momotaro, just before he gets to the island, and the way he strides, it’s almost too confident. Like, come on, give us a little worry, kid! 😂
The fighting sequences are... brief. Very brief. More like a series of quick, illustrative gestures than actual brawls. You don’t really see a lot of complex action, which makes sense for the time.
It’s interesting, how much story they pack into such a short runtime. No wasted motion, even if some of the animation itself feels a bit clunky or repetitive.
The quiet moments, like the old couple just sitting together, they felt surprisingly warm. It gave a nice little anchor to the whole fantastical journey.
But then, there are these bits where the cuts feel a little abrupt. Like, one scene just kinda ends and the next one just starts, without much of a gentle hand-off.
You can tell this film isn't trying to be anything more than what it is: a simple telling of a beloved tale. No deep hidden meanings here, just a hero and his animal pals.
I kept thinking about how different this is from, say, Little Women, where the drama is all internal. Here, it’s all external, all about the quest.
The ending, it’s pretty straightforward. Good wins, bad loses, everyone goes home happy. No big surprises, which is fine.
Overall, it’s a neat little piece of film history. Not something you’d probably revisit often, unless you’re really into the origins of animation. But for a quick peek into a classic story, it does the job. It feels like a story you'd hear by a fire, really.

IMDb —
1923
Community
Log in to comment.