DbcultAccessing Vault...
Cult Review
Archivist John
Senior Editor
Short answer: Yes, but it’s flawed and you should approach it with an understanding of its historical context and limitations.
Private Izzy Murphy, directed by Frank Borzage, stars Fletcher Tolbert as Isadore 'Izzy' Goldberg, a man who changes his name to Patrick Murphy to fit into the Irish community in New York City. His romantic entanglements and military service during World War I are woven together in a tale that challenges societal norms and expectations of the time.
Frank Borzage, known for his delicate handling of emotion and social issues, directs Private Izzy Murphy with a blend of comedy and drama. The film’s setting in the early 1920s provides a rich backdrop for exploring themes of identity, family, and cultural acceptance.
The cinematography is striking, with the use of natural lighting and the New York City setting contributing to the film's authenticity. The set design, although basic by modern standards, effectively captures the atmosphere of the Irish neighborhood.
At the center of the film is Fletcher Tolbert as Izzy. His performance is nuanced and captivating, especially in scenes where he grapples with the consequences of his name change. Supporting actors like George Jessel and Gustav von Seyffertitz provide comic relief and depth to the secondary characters.
The plot follows Izzy as he falls in love with Eileen Cohannigan and enlists in the military during World War I. His experiences in France and his subsequent return home are filled with moments of both comedy and drama. The film culminates in a heartfelt resolution that challenges the societal norms of the time.
Private Izzy Murphy is a film that works because of its engaging performances and exploration of themes relevant to the time. It is not without its flaws, however. The reliance on dated stereotypes and a somewhat predictable narrative structure can be off-putting for modern audiences.
Frank Borzage's direction is subtle and effective. He balances the film's comedic elements with the emotional depth required to explore the film's themes. His handling of the wartime scenes, particularly Izzy's heroic rescue, is particularly well-executed, adding a layer of authenticity to the narrative.
The cinematography is a highlight of the film. The use of natural lighting and the New York City setting contribute to the film's authenticity. The overseas hospital scenes, although basic in production, are shot with a sense of realism that enhances the emotional impact of the story.
At the center of the film is Fletcher Tolbert's portrayal of Izzy. His performance is nuanced and captivating. Scenes where he grapples with the consequences of his name change are particularly effective. Supporting actors like George Jessel and Gustav von Seyffertitz provide comic relief and depth to the secondary characters. The chemistry between Tolbert and Patsy Ruth Miller as Eileen is particularly charming.
Private Izzy Murphy is a film that works because of its engaging performances and exploration of themes relevant to the time. It is not without its flaws, however. The reliance on dated stereotypes and a somewhat predictable narrative structure can be off-putting for modern audiences. Still, it is a film that deserves to be seen for its historical significance and the skillful performances.
Pros:
Cons:
Private Izzy Murphy is a film that works because of its engaging performances and exploration of themes relevant to the time. It is not without its flaws, however. The reliance on dated stereotypes and a somewhat predictable narrative structure can be off-putting for modern audiences. Still, it is a film that deserves to be seen for its historical significance and the skillful performances.
IMDb 4.6
1919
Community
Log in to comment.
