6.1/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 6.1/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Puppet Show remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Honestly, only if you’re a completionist for early animation or have a soft spot for the slightly cursed-looking versions of classic characters. If you want a smooth, polished narrative, stay away—this is pure chaos.
There is a real weirdness to seeing Oswald without his luck. He’s just a guy trying to put on a show in a barn, and it feels a bit desperate, honestly. 🤡
The animation has that bouncy, loose style where limbs stretch like taffy for no reason. It reminds me a bit of the frantic energy in The Diving Fool, but with more sawdust and fewer high-dives.
The show within the show is where things get genuinely strange. The movements are jerky, and the scale shifts constantly, which I’m sure was just a lack of budget or planning back in the day.
It feels like a fever dream. One minute Oswald is pulling strings, and the next, the puppets are acting like they have actual agency, which is a classic trope but still unsettling.
There’s a moment where a puppet just flops around on the stage, and the timing is so off it becomes kind of hilarious. You can practically hear the animators rushing to get it finished before the week was up.
It doesn't have the grand, sweeping feel of something like Das Blumenwunder, but it isn't trying to be that, either. It’s a scrappy little cartoon that doesn't care if you think it’s pretty.
If you've seen Axe Me Another, you know the type of frantic, almost aggressive humor they were going for. This isn't quite as sharp, but it’s got enough of that weird, old-school charm to keep you watching until the end.
It’s not a masterpiece. It’s not even a particularly good cartoon. But it’s there, existing in its own little void, and sometimes that’s enough. 🐰