7.1/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 7.1/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Stowaway remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Alright, so “Stowaway” is absolutely worth a watch today, *if* you're in the mood for pure, unadulterated 1930s Shirley Temple. If you find her brand of precocious cuteness a little too much, or if you prefer your old movies without spontaneous singing, you might want to give it a pass. But for a dose of sunshine and some genuinely clever moments, it’s a real treat. For fans of classic musicals and feel-good stories, it's a solid Sunday afternoon pick. For those who can't stand old movie pacing or child stars, well, you know.
The premise is simple enough: little Ching-Ching (Shirley Temple, obviously) is lost in Shanghai. Like, really lost. She just wanders onto a boat and becomes a stowaway, which is where the title comes from. She’s found by Tommy Randall, played by Robert Young, who’s a dashing American playboy type. He's got a girlfriend, Susan Parker (Alice Faye), who’s quite the looker and a singer herself. What follows is a whirlwind of trying to figure out what to do with Ching-Ching while she, in her own special way, tries to play matchmaker for the two adults.
One thing that hits you right away is the sheer spectacle of 1930s Shanghai as imagined by Hollywood. It’s vibrant, busy, and sometimes a little… *much*. There are a lot of extras milling about, though some of the street scenes sometimes feel a touch staged, like a very busy backlot. You can almost feel the studio trying to convey a bustling city without, you know, actually being there. The market scenes are particularly colorful. 🏮
Shirley Temple, as Ching-Ching, is just a force of nature. She speaks fluent Chinese, which is quite impressive for a six-year-old, even if it's clearly dubbed over or very rehearsed. Her quick wit and charm are on full display, especially when she’s bantering with the adults. She’s never annoying, which is a common pitfall for child actors. She just sort of *is*.
Robert Young as Tommy is pretty charming. He starts out a bit of a carefree bachelor, but he quickly falls for Ching-Ching's innocent appeal. His scenes where he's trying to be serious, but you can see him softening, are quite sweet. There’s one bit where he’s trying to tell her off, and his voice just cracks with affection. It’s a good little moment.
Alice Faye, too. Her character Susan is initially a bit guarded, maybe even a little jealous of the attention Tommy gives Ching-Ching. But she comes around. Her singing voice is truly something else. There’s a scene where she sings to Ching-Ching, and it’s just beautiful. You really feel the warmth.
The musical numbers are, as expected, a highlight. Shirley does her thing, singing and dancing with incredible energy. There's this one sequence where she does vocal impressions of various singers. It’s a classic Temple move, and it's still pretty neat to watch her pull it off. You can tell she really worked on those. The way she just *launches* into a song, out of nowhere, is just pure old Hollywood magic. ✨
Now, about the Shanghai setting and the depiction of the local characters. It's a product of its time, for sure. Sammee Tong plays Chang, a local who helps Ching-Ching, and he’s endearing, but some of the accents and comedic beats involving the Chinese characters haven't aged perfectly. It's not *malicious*, but it certainly doesn't feel quite right now. It's something you notice, and then you just kind of… move past it, if you can.
The plot itself is pretty light. It’s mostly an excuse to get Shirley into various cute situations and bring the romantic leads together. The legal battle over Ching-Ching's guardianship in the third act feels a little rushed, like they suddenly remembered they needed some stakes. But it’s all resolved with a big, happy bow. You know how these movies go. Nobody’s really in peril for long.
I distinctly remember a scene where Ching-Ching is trying to clean up some rowdy sailors' singing. She just walks up and starts conducting them. And they, of course, immediately fall in line. It’s a bit silly, but that’s the power of Shirley Temple on screen, I guess. She can charm anyone.
The movie does have a few moments where the dialogue feels a little stilted, like the actors are waiting for their cue a beat too long. It’s not a huge deal, but you can catch it. And some of the scene transitions are a bit abrupt, just cutting from one place to another without much fanfare. 🎬
Ultimately, “Stowaway” is a sweet, if slightly dated, piece of cinematic history. It’s a testament to Shirley Temple’s enduring appeal. You watch it for her, for the smiles, and for a glimpse into a simpler, more innocent (on screen, anyway) era of filmmaking. Don't expect a deep, philosophical drama. Just enjoy the ride.

IMDb 7
1919
Community
Log in to comment.