4.6/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 4.6/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Explorer remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Honestly, only if you are a total animation nerd who collects 1930s scraps. If you want a smooth story or, you know, things that make logical sense, look elsewhere. People who enjoy weird, jerky black-and-white animation will get a kick out of it, but everyone else will probably just be confused by the noise.
The whole thing starts with Farmer Al Falfa. He looks exactly like you think he does—that classic, grumpy old man face that defined the era. He builds this flying machine that looks like it is held together by sheer willpower and spit. The animation is... well, it is 1931, so it is a bit stiff. It feels like every frame is fighting the one before it.
Watching him travel to the North Pole is a lesson in patience. The background loops are aggressive. You see the same cloud move past his face about thirty times before anything actually happens. It gives the whole thing this weirdly hypnotic, repetitive vibe. It reminded me a bit of the frantic energy in Edgar Takes the Cake, but with more snow and less dessert.
There is no real plot here, just a sequence of bad luck for Al Falfa. He hits stuff. He crashes. He gets annoyed. It is very physical. There is a specific bit where he encounters an ice floe that feels like it goes on for an eternity. It isn't exactly groundbreaking, but there is a certain charm to how unpolished it is.
It’s not trying to be a deep cinematic statement. It is just a Saturday morning time-waster from nearly a century ago. You can almost feel the animators just trying to get the thing finished so they could go home. That honesty is kind of refreshing, in a weird way. It makes me think of the slightly forgotten energy in The Range Pirate. Sometimes you just need a cartoon to be a cartoon.
Is it better than the stuff people were making later in the decade? Probably not. But it has a grit to it. It’s noisy. It’s rough. It’s very 1931. 🧊✈️

IMDb —
1917
Community
Log in to comment.