DbcultAccessing Vault...
6.7/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 6.7/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Guilty Generation remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
So, is The Guilty Generation worth digging up today? Well, it depends on your mood. If you’re into those early talkies, the kind where the melodrama is cranked way up and people really *emote*, then yeah, you might find something here. It’s got that old-timey feel, a sort of grim charm. But if you hate movies that take their time, or you just can’t stand characters who make obviously bad decisions, then this one will probably just annoy you. Don't expect subtle.
The whole thing kicks off with a classic setup: two families, a blood feud, and two young people who just shouldn't be together. We've got Marco Ricca, the big shot bootlegger, and his son, Joe. Then there’s Mike Palmieri, Marco’s ex-partner, and his daughter, Maria. You can already see where this is going, right? 🤦♀️
Leo Carrillo as Marco Ricca is just… *a lot*. He’s supposed to be this brutal, powerful guy, and he certainly acts it. He shouts, he paces, he gesticulates. It’s like watching a stage play, honestly. Every emotion is big, bold, and right on the surface. When he’s angry, you know he’s angry. Like, you *really* know it. His son, Joe, played by Robert Young, tries to be the good kid, but you can feel the pressure just weighing him down.
Barbara Weeks as Maria Palmieri is the other half of our forbidden romance. She’s got this defiant spark, but it often gets swallowed by the sheer *drama* around her. There's a scene where she's arguing with her father about Joe, and the way she pleads, it's very 1930s Hollywood. A little over the top, maybe, but you feel for her anyway. She’s stuck between a rock and a hard place, you know?
The feud between Ricca and Palmieri is what really drives the movie. It’s relentless. They hate each other with such passion. It’s not just business, it’s deeply personal. You see it in every glare, every tense meeting. There’s one bit where they're in a dark room, just staring each other down, and the silence hangs so heavy it almost feels like a punch. Not subtle, but effective.
And Boris Karloff pops up! Not in a big role, mind you. He’s just there, a henchman named Tony, looking menacing in the background. It's a blink-and-you-miss-it kind of part, but it's cool to see him before he became *the* Boris Karloff everyone remembers. He’s got this intense stare even then. Like, he doesn't even need to say anything, you just know he's not a guy you want to mess with. Definitely one of those little details you catch if you're really paying attention to the smaller players.
The pacing of this film is pretty interesting. It starts off quick, setting up the whole bad blood thing, then it settles into a rhythm. There are moments that drag a little, especially when characters are just talking about their feelings for what feels like forever. Then suddenly, BAM, another violent outburst, and you’re jolted back into it. It’s not always smooth, but it keeps you on your toes.
You can tell they were still figuring out sound in movies back then. Some of the dialogue feels a little stilted, like the actors are trying *really* hard to speak clearly into the mics. And the background noise? Sometimes it's barely there, other times it's oddly prominent. It’s part of the charm, though, that raw, unpolished sound. It gives it a very specific feel.
The ending, as you might expect from a 'Romeo and Juliet' story, isn't exactly sunshine and rainbows. It’s bleak, honestly. The film doesn't pull its punches there. It really wants you to feel the weight of these characters' choices and the senselessness of the feud. And it mostly succeeds in that. You walk away thinking, *man, that was rough*.
So, yeah. The Guilty Generation is a heavy watch. It's not perfect, not by a long shot. The acting can be overblown, the plot a bit predictable. But it's got a certain raw energy to it, a historical curiosity that makes it worth a look if you're into the era. It's got heart, even if that heart is breaking most of the time. Just don't go in expecting a light comedy. Far from it. 💔
IMDb 6.3
1928
Community
Log in to comment.
