6.8/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 6.8/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Pagan remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you're looking for something to watch on a lazy Sunday, The Pagan is actually a decent choice. You should watch it if you like old movies that feel like a vacation, even if that vacation has a really mean guy trying to ruin the fun.
People who hate slow, silent-era storytelling will probably be bored out of their minds. But if you like seeing how movies used to handle 'tropical' romance, it's a bit of a trip. 🌴
Ramon Novarro is the main guy, Henry. He spends a lot of time just hanging out, singing, and looking very happy with his life.
He has this incredible smile that feels like it could light up the whole island. It’s hard not to like him even when he's being a bit lazy.
Then you have Donald Crisp playing the villain, Slater. He is a 'religious' man but he’s actually just a big bully who wants everything for himself.
Slater wears these stiff, dark clothes that look so uncomfortable in the heat. It makes him look like a walking shadow compared to everyone else. 👤
The girl he's 'protecting' is Madge, played by Dorothy Janis. She’s fine, but she doesn't have a lot to do except look worried or in love.
There is this one scene where Henry is singing 'Pagan Love Song' while swimming or near the water. It’s a part-talkie, so the sound kicks in just for the song.
It’s a little awkward because the transition from silence to sound isn't very smooth. You can tell the studio was just desperate to show off their new audio tech.
The water looks really beautiful in this film. I kept thinking about how much work it must have been to get those cameras out there back in 1929.
The way the light hits the palm trees actually feels real, not like a studio set. It reminded me a little bit of the atmosphere in The Savage, though that one is different.
There's a scene where Slater is trying to force Madge to be with him and it's genuinely creepy. Donald Crisp is really good at being a jerk you want to see get punched.
I noticed that Henry’s house is basically just a big open room. It looks way more comfortable than the stuffy house Slater lives in.
The movie doesn't really care about the plot too much for the first half. It just wants you to watch people walk around and enjoy the scenery.
Some of the acting is a bit much, with the big eye movements and heavy sighing. But that's just how it was back then, I guess.
I think Renée Adorée is in this too, but her role didn't stick in my head as much. She was much more memorable in other things from that era like Evangeline which came out around the same time.
The ending is a bit rushed. It’s like they realized they only had ten minutes left and had to finish the fight quickly.
There’s a moment with a boat that felt a bit clumsy in how it was edited. One second they are far away, the next they are right there. 🚣♂️
But honestly, the movie is mostly about the vibe of the island and Novarro being a heartthrob. It’s not trying to be a deep philosophy lesson.
The music is pretty catchy too. I found myself humming that one song for like an hour after it finished.
It’s a bit weird seeing white actors play 'natives,' but if you can get past that historical baggage, it’s a sweet story. It’s definitely better than some of the other stuff I’ve seen from that year, like maybe A Modern Du Barry which felt way more stiff.
I liked the dog. There’s a dog in some scenes and he just looks happy to be there.
Anyway, it’s a short watch. If you want to see a movie where a guy chooses love over money and looks good doing it, give it a go. 🥥
It’s not a masterpiece or anything. It’s just a nice, slightly dusty piece of history with some good lighting.

IMDb —
1924
Community
Log in to comment.