7.3/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 7.3/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. The Way of Lost Souls remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you have a soft spot for grainy, late-silent movies where everyone looks like they desperately need a nap and a warm blanket, you should watch this. The Way of Lost Souls is for the folks who like staring at crashing waves and feeling sad.
Action fans will hate it. It moves slower than a snail on a cold day, but that is kinda the point.
Pola Negri plays Louise, and man, her face is everything in this. She doesn't even need to move her mouth to tell you she's miserable.
The story is simple enough. She marries this lighthouse keeper named Peter because she wants to escape her old life in the city.
But then Maxim, her old flame, shows up looking for a place to hide. He is played by Warwick Ward, who has the most suspicious mustache I have ever seen on film.
The lighthouse itself feels like a character. It is cramped and dark, and you can practically smell the kerosene leaking out of the lamps.
I love the scene where they are all sitting at the table. Nobody is talking, obviously, but the way they look at thier soup is incredibly tense.
There is a weird moment where the camera lingers on a piece of bread for way too long. I think it was supposed to be symbolic, but it mostly just made me hungry.
It reminds me a bit of the atmosphere in The Fall of the House of Usher, but with more salt water. It has that same heavy feeling where you know something bad is coming.
The husband, played by Hans Rehmann, is just so earnest. You feel bad for him because he clearly has no idea his wife is hiding a fugitive in the spare room.
The shadows in this movie are massive. Sometimes they cover half the actors' faces, which makes everyone look like a villain even when they are just being nice.
It is definitely more artistic than something like It Happened Out West. It’s not trying to be fun; it’s trying to make you feel trapped.
The ending gets a little chaotic. People start running up and down those spiral stairs and I got a bit dizzy just watching it.
I noticed one shot where the wind is blowing so hard that the actors can barely keep thier eyes open. It feels very real, not like a studio set at all.
Warwick Ward does this thing with his eyes where he looks like he's constantly calculating how much money is in your pocket. He’s great at being sleazy.
The movie is also known as The Woman He Scorned, which sounds like a cheap romance novel. The title The Way of Lost Souls fits the depressing vibe way better.
If you’ve seen The New Babylon, you might appreciate the visual style here, even if the editing isn't quite as wild. It’s got that late-20s polish where they finally figured out how to make silence feel loud.
Sometimes the plot feels a bit thin, like they were stretching out a short story to fill the time. A few scenes of people just walking across the rocks could have been cut way down.
But then Pola Negri does that thing where she looks directly into the lens. It's like she's looking through the screen and right at you ⚓.
It is a solid watch if you're in the mood for some high-stakes moping. Just don't expect a happy ending or any jokes.
The print I saw had some scratches, but it actually added to the feeling of it all. It felt like watching a ghost story that someone found in a basement.
I’ll probably think about that lighthouse for a few days. It's not a perfect movie, but it stays with you. 🌊

IMDb —
1918
Community
Log in to comment.