Try and Get It: A Classic Comedy of Errors - Film Review

The film Try and Get It, directed by the less well-known Jules Furthman and Eugene P. Lyle Jr., is a delightful slice of early 1930s American comedy that bridges the gap between the silent era and the talkies. The plot revolves around the romantic and professional dilemmas faced by two young bill collectors, Joseph Merrill and Glenn Collins, as they attempt to collect a debt from Timothy Perrin, a wealthy cement manufacturer and investor in a women's dress shop. This narrative forms the backbone of the story, which is peppered with witty dialogue and an engaging mix of romance and comedy.

The characters are well-defined and the performances are a joy to watch. Bryant Washburn as Joseph Merrill and Edward Everett Horton as Glenn Collins provide the perfect combination of charm and wit that is essential for the success of a comedy. Their chemistry is palpable, and the audience can't help but root for them as they navigate their way through the challenges of their respective tasks.

At the heart of the film is the relationship between Joseph Merrill and Timothy Perrin's daughter, Rhoda, played by Billie Dove. This sub-plot adds a layer of depth to the film, as we see Merrill's genuine affection for Rhoda juxtaposed against his professional duties. The interactions between Merrill and Rhoda are tender and romantic, providing a counterpoint to the comedic elements of the story.

The setting of the film is also noteworthy. The 1930s backdrop provides an authentic atmosphere that complements the story's themes. The attention to detail in the sets and costumes gives the film a timeless quality, making it feel both period-specific and universally appealing.

One of the standout aspects of Try and Get It is its clever writing. The dialogue is sharp and witty, with a mix of banter and heartfelt moments. The script, penned by Jules Furthman and Eugene P. Lyle Jr., deftly balances the comedic elements with the romantic storyline. The humor is both subtle and overt, allowing for a variety of laughs, from the clever wordplay to the physical comedy.

The film's production values are commendable. The cinematography captures the essence of the 1930s with a blend of natural lighting and staged scenes. The use of color, particularly the sea blue hues that are evident in Rhoda's attire, adds a visual appeal that enhances the emotional tone of the film. The music, while not overly intrusive, serves to heighten the mood and underscore the emotional beats of the story.

It's worth noting that Try and Get It stands out among its contemporaries. Films like Sure-Fire Flint and The Happy Warrior are more grounded in drama and less focused on the comedic elements that Try and Get It excels at. While A Corner in Cotton and My Dog, Pal are more lighthearted, they lack the depth and character development that Try and Get It offers.

Overall, Try and Get It is a delightful and underappreciated gem from the early days of Hollywood. It offers a perfect blend of romance, comedy, and historical charm that makes it a must-watch for fans of classic cinema. The performances, the writing, and the overall execution all come together to create a memorable experience that transcends the boundaries of its era.

Whether you're a fan of early 1930s comedies or simply enjoy a well-crafted film, Try and Get It is a film that deserves a place in the pantheon of classic American cinema. It's a testament to the enduring power of well-written stories and the timeless appeal of a good laugh.