West of Broadway Review: A Rural Western with a Twist of Golf and Danger

Is this film worth watching? 'West of Broadway' is a rural Western that, while not groundbreaking, offers a thoughtful exploration of gender roles and the clash of traditions. It's worth a watch for those interested in the genre and its more nuanced representations of rural life. However, if you're looking for a high-octane, action-packed Western, you might be disappointed.

Opening Scene

The film opens with Bruce Elwood, a rugged Wyoming rancher, sending a telegram to Freddie Hayden, a golf champion, asking him to come teach lessons at his Cowboy Golf Club. This sets the stage for a series of events that will challenge traditional gender roles and test the boundaries of what a rural Western can be.

Acting and Characters

The performances are solid, with George M. Hall delivering a nuanced portrayal of Bruce Elwood. Priscilla Dean as Freddie Hayden brings a mix of charm and authority, making her character both likable and intriguing. The supporting cast, including Arnold Gray and Walter Long, add depth to the story with their well-crafted characters.

Directing and Cinematography

Director John H. Auer and cinematographer Arthur J. Keller create a visually engaging film, capturing the vastness of Wyoming and the subtleties of rural life. The golf scenes are particularly well-shot, highlighting the beauty and complexity of the game. The use of natural lighting and wide shots effectively convey the isolation and vastness of the landscape.

Cinematic perspective: Exploring the visual vocabulary of West of Broadway (1926) through its definitive frames.

Pacing and Tone

The pacing is steady, allowing the audience to fully immerse themselves in the story. The tone oscillates between humor and tension, making for an engaging viewing experience. The film's pacing is crucial in balancing the quieter moments with the more action-oriented sequences involving cattle rustling.

Is this film worth watching?

This film works because... It offers a fresh take on the Western genre, blending traditional themes with modern sensibilities. The film's exploration of gender roles and the clash of traditions is both subtle and impactful. The golf lessons provide a unique setting for character development and conflict.

This film fails because... Some of the characters, particularly the cowboys, feel one-dimensional at times. The resolution of the cattle rustling subplot is somewhat rushed, leaving some loose ends. Additionally, the film's reliance on golf as a central plot device might not resonate with all audiences.

You should watch it if... You are interested in a thoughtful exploration of gender roles and the intersection of tradition and modernity in rural America. If you enjoy quirky Westerns that push the boundaries of the genre, 'West of Broadway' is definitely worth your time.

Key Takeaways

• Best for: Fans of thoughtful Westerns with nuanced characters and unique settings.
• Not for: Viewers looking for a high-octane, action-packed Western. Those who find the golf lessons and character development too slow might also find it less engaging.
• Standout element: The golf scenes and the unique setting of a rural Wyoming golf club.
• Biggest flaw: Some characters, particularly the cowboys, feel underdeveloped.

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Nuanced exploration of gender roles, well-crafted characters, engaging golf scenes, visually appealing cinematography.
• Cons: Some characters feel one-dimensional, rushed resolution of the cattle rustling subplot, reliance on golf as a central plot device.

Verdict

While 'West of Broadway' may not be a classic Western, it offers a fresh and thought-provoking take on the genre. It works because it challenges traditional gender roles and explores the complexities of rural life. However, it fails in several areas, including underdeveloped characters and a rushed ending. If you're willing to look beyond the surface and appreciate a well-crafted, character-driven Western, 'West of Broadway' is definitely worth your time.