5.5/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 5.5/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. What a Widow! remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
“What a Widow!” from 1930? Yeah, it’s a bit of a dusty one, but if you’re into seeing how they did “rich people problems” almost a century ago, it’s kinda charming. You’ll probably dig this if you enjoy silent-era glamor or early talkie attempts at sophisticated comedy. But if you’re looking for snappy dialogue or deep plots, you’ll find yourself fidgeting pretty fast. This one’s definitely not for everyone. 😬
So, Gloria Swanson. She’s Yvonne. Her old husband kicks the bucket, and boom! Five million dollars. You know, a classic setup. The movie doesn't really dwell on the *grief* part, which is probably for the best. It’s more about the *what now?* part. And for Yvonne, it means Paris. Of course.
Paris in this movie is less a city and more a *vibe*. All grand hotels and fancy parties. Everyone dressed to the nines. You get a sense of this world that just doesn't exist anymore, which is neat. They really tried to sell that aspirational lifestyle.
Swanson herself, she’s just… **a presence**. She glides through scenes. Even when the dialogue is a little clunky – and oh boy, some of it is – her expressions do so much work. There's this one moment where she's at a ball, and a gentleman says something utterly forgettable. But her tiny eye roll, almost imperceptible, tells you everything. She’s already over it. 😂
Then we have the two main fellas. There’s Jose, played by Lew Cody. He’s the slick, charming playboy type. All smiles and smooth lines. He’s definitely got that *continental charm* down. You can almost see him practicing his suave looks in a mirror.
The other one is Gerry, the lawyer, played by Owen Moore. He’s the sensible one. The guy who’s actually trying to manage her money and, you know, offer practical advice. He’s often just standing there, looking a bit bewildered by all the high-society antics. His quiet exasperation is actually pretty funny sometimes.
The whole film plays out as this kind of push-and-pull between the flashy allure of Jose and the steady reliability of Gerry. It’s not exactly a groundbreaking love triangle, but it works for what it is. You kind of root for the lawyer, even though Jose is undeniably more… *sparkly*.
One scene that stuck with me: Yvonne is trying on a truly outrageous hat. Like, feathers and sparkles everywhere. She looks in the mirror, and for a second, you see her question it. Then she gives a little nod, like, “Yep, this is me now.” It’s a small, quick thing, but it humanizes her beyond just being a rich widow.
The early sound design is, well, *early sound design*. Sometimes the music swells a little too dramatically. Or someone whispers, and it sounds like they’re shouting. It adds a certain charm, honestly. Like watching a play where the actors haven't quite figured out their mic levels yet.
There are these party scenes. Lots of people dancing, but the background chatter feels a bit… thin. Like they only had five extras who could talk at once. You notice these things. It's not a flaw, really, just a peek into how films were made then.
Lew Cody, as Jose, has this habit of always adjusting his tie. Every other scene, a little tug. It's a tiny detail but it really sells his character as someone very concerned with appearances. It's almost *too* perfect. Makes him feel a bit artificial, in a good way for the character.
The pacing is interesting. Some scenes just **linger**. Like, really linger. A shot of Yvonne looking out a window. You expect something profound to happen, but she just… sighs. And then the scene moves on. It’s a bold choice, or maybe they just didn't know how to cut it tighter. Either way, it makes you pay attention.
It’s not a deep film. You won’t walk away pondering the meaning of life or anything. It's a snapshot. A very stylish, often silly, snapshot of a very specific kind of wealth and romance. You get to see Gloria Swanson just *be* Gloria Swanson, which, for fans, is probably enough.
Honestly, it felt like a pleasant afternoon distraction. Not something you’d write a thesis on, but for a glimpse into old Hollywood and a chuckle at some very charming, very dated romantic tropes, it’s worth a look. Especially if you enjoy spotting those little early talkie quirks. ✨

IMDb —
1927
Community
Log in to comment.