Recommendations
Curated Recommendations Seeking the Same Brilliance as What Shall I Do?: Cult Guide

“Discover the best cult films and cinematic recommendations similar to What Shall I Do? (1924).”
If you found yourself captivated by the nuanced performance of What Shall I Do? (1924), the profound questions raised in 1924 still require cinematic answers today. Experience the United States influence in these recommendations that echo What Shall I Do?.
The What Shall I Do? Phenomenon
What Shall I Do? remains a monumental achievement to provide a definitive example of John G. Adolfi's stylistic genius.
Under the name of Jack Nelson, Don McLean goes to work in his father's factory. He meets a restaurant cashier, Jeanie; they are married and have a child. Stricken by amnesia as a result of an accident, Jack forgets his family and returns to his former life. Eventually his memory is restored, and he is reunited with his wife and child.
Did you know?
What Shall I Do? was a significant production in United States, showcasing the immense talent of Betty Morrissey, Joan Standing, Ralph McCullough. It continues to be a top recommendation for anyone studying Drama history.
Curated Recommendations Seeking the Same Brilliance as What Shall I Do?
Based on the unique nuanced performance of What Shall I Do?, our vault has identified these titles as the most compelling follow-up experiences for fans of Drama cinema:
Dir: [object Object]
Joyce's mother keeps her younger daughter in the background so that Polly, the elder daughter, can monopolize all the eligible young men, especially Tom. Although Tom is Polly's choice, she decides to pique his interest by flirting with Harry. Joyce, who likes Tom herself, decides to defeat her sister's plan by having Tom pretend that he likes her. Soon, the pretense turns to love and Tom proposes to Joyce. To test his sincerity, Joyce jumps into shark-infested waters and almost loses her life. Tom visits her constantly in the hospital and finds that his operation on her heart was quite successful.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
After running away from an orphanage, young Alicia Jones disguises herself as a boy and gets a job on a farm. She falls in love with Harry Deigan, a farmhand who knows her secret, but when the farm's owner finds out, he fires her. Alicia is forced to return to the city, where she meets a wealthy man who adopts her. He turns out to be Thomas Deigan, the half-brother of Alicia's love Harry Deigan. Harry finds out that Thomas is his half-brother, but also finds out something that could change his, Thomas', and Alicia's lives forever.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
Fearing that his daughter Patsy is becoming a tomboy, John Primmel sends her to a friend back East for education and refinement. Arriving in New York, Patsy discovers that her father's friend has died and his apartment is now inhabited by his son, Dick Hewitt. Dick allows Patsy to stay, and they hire a maid, a housekeeper, and a butler. One night, while Dick is drunk, adventuress Helene Arnold tricks him into marrying her. Soon after, Dick's sister Alice arrives and urges him to marry Patsy, whom he really loves. Helene then threatens to expose Dick unless he pays her $10,000 hush money. Dick refuses and the next evening, while at a party, Helene tells the guests that she has an important announcement to make. Just as she is about to expose Dick, his butler appears and Helene gasps, announces that she is going to Europe to become a nurse, and rushes from the house. The butler then informs Dick that Helene is his wife who deserted him years earlier. Dick's marriage thus nullified, he is free to marry Patsy.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
Elaine Brooks marries Robert Ames, a member of the United States Department of Justice. The Germans, who are anxious to secure some papers that Robert possesses, employ Viola Durand to get to Robert through Elaine. Viola tricks Elaine into giving her the papers and also procures a letter that seems to establish Elaine as the traitor. George Blair, an official at the Department of Justice, finally tricks Viola into confessing her guilt, thus clearing Elaine's name.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
Mary Ann, an orphan leading a life of drudgery, falls in love with a promising but equally penniless composer, John Lonsdale.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
French Secret Service agent and boxer Henri D'Alour uncovers a plot to con the government out of millions of francs in its purchase of machinery.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
An English aristocrat visiting Norway falls in love with Thelma, daughter of a Viking-like Norse landowner, and this first part is an idyllic story. He marries her and takes her to England. Society women, one of whom has been infatuated with the young man, are disappointed, because Thelma is not only beautiful but has pretty manners and is popular. There is a very melodramatic conspiracy to break her heart by making her suspect her husband. It works and she runs away back to her Norway home. Her husband follows and the happy ending unites the two in the old Norse homestead.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
Unbekownst to each other, Charles Macklin and his widowed father Arthur are having an affair with an exotic dancer called The Sphinx. When both come to see her at the same time, Charles gets upset, denounces the Sphinx, and is knocked out by Arthur. Arthur then decides to marry the Sphinx, while Charles then resumes his affair with Frances, to whom he was engaged before he met the Sphinx.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
Wealthy playboy Jack Edmunds spends some time in a small mountain town, where he makes the acquaintance of local girl Caprtice Talbert and invites her to his apartment. When Caprice's father finds out about it--although nothing happened--he forces the two to marry, and the newlyweds move to Jack's home in the city. Tensions arise between the two as Jack is still resentful over the "shotgun wedding" and Caprice finds that she can't bear living in the big city and wants to return home.
View Details
Dir: [object Object]
The true story of Edith Cavell, a British nurse who served with the underground in Belgium during the First World War.
View DetailsCinematic Comparison Matrix
Analysis relative to What Shall I Do?
| Film Title | Atmosphere | Complexity | Similarity |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Modern Cinderella | Tense | Dense | 89% Match |
| The Ragged Princess | Gritty | Layered | 94% Match |
| Patsy | Gothic | Abstract | 97% Match |
| The Burden of Proof | Ethereal | High | 91% Match |
| Merely Mary Ann | Gothic | Linear | 98% Match |
This guide was algorithmically generated using the cinematic metadata of John G. Adolfi's archive. Last updated: 4/30/2026.
Back to What Shall I Do? Details →Community
Comments
Log in to comment.
Loading comments…