Summary
A vibrant confection of early cinematic whimsy, "How Could You, Jean?" unfurls the delightful predicament of Jean Mackaye, a social butterfly abruptly divested of her gilded existence. Rather than succumbing to despair, our intrepid heroine, possessed of an indomitable spirit and a knack for reinvention, sheds her high-society trappings for the humble garb of a Salvation Army recruit. This audacious transformation is merely the prelude to her ingenious infiltration of the eccentric Bonner household, where she assumes the guise of a 'Swedish cook.' The Bonners themselves, a delightfully oblivious elderly couple, are far too engrossed in the arcane world of entomology to notice the domestic upheaval brewing beneath their very noses. Amidst their insect-laden studies, a charmingly earnest Swedish hired man, Oscar, finds himself utterly smitten with the enigmatic new culinary talent. However, the romantic comedy truly ignites with the arrival of Ted Burton, a scion of wealth whose own heart is irrevocably captured by Jean's disguised allure. His infatuation leads to an elaborate charade, as he orchestrates Oscar's departure to claim the coveted kitchen post himself. The plot thickens further with the suspicious arrival of Burton Sr., Ted's curmudgeonly millionaire father, who, baffled by his son's sudden domesticity, takes up residence as a boarder. What follows is a series of escalating comedic misunderstandings and narrow escapes, culminating in Jean's heroic intervention that saves the elder Burton's life. This act of bravery, stripping away the layers of pretense, ultimately secures the crusty patriarch's heartfelt blessing for the union of his enamored son and the surprisingly capable 'Swedish cook,' proving that true character, and love, can blossom in the most unexpected of guises.
Synopsis
When Jean Mackaye, a pretty and resourceful young woman, discovers that she has lost her fortune, she dresses in Salvation Army clothing and secures a job in the Bonner home as a Swedish cook. Mr. and Mrs. Bonner, an elderly couple preoccupied with the study of insects, are too busy to notice that their Swedish hired man Oscar is falling in love with Jean. However, Ted Burton, the son of a cranky old millionaire, soon falls so deeply in love with her that he convinces Oscar to resign and applies for the position himself. Burton, Sr., anxious to discover the reason for his son's odd behavior, becomes a boarder in the house. Following a series of adventures in which Jean saves the old man's life, Burton blesses the union of his son and the "Swedish cook."
Review Excerpt
"
Stepping back into the golden age of silent cinema offers a unique pleasure, a window into storytelling that relied on gesture, expression, and the sheer charisma of its stars. Among these luminous figures, Mary Pickford, 'America's Sweetheart,' shone brightest, and her work in films like 1918's How Could You, Jean? provides a delightful testament to her enduring appeal. This isn't just a historical curiosity; it's a vibrant, heartwarming comedy of errors that, even a century later, manages..."
