Summary
In the soot-stained corridors of a collegiate boarding house, Jane exists as a ghostly auxiliary, a 'slavey' whose identity is subsumed by the drudgery of her station. Her quiet devotion to John Adams, a student navigating the precarious climb toward social mobility, remains an unread manuscript. John, blinded by the incandescent allure of the socialite Ethelda Rathbone, views Jane only as a functional fixture of his environment. The narrative's pivot occurs when Jane, in an act of sacrificial benevolence, exhausts her meager pittance to rent a dress suit for John, facilitating his entry into the elite sphere of a university ball. This borrowed elegance is violently stripped away when his classmates, in a display of juvenile cruelty, ruin the garment, leading to Jane’s public castigation by a rapacious merchant. Her salvation arrives in the form of Frederick Verstner, a wealthy photographer who perceives a latent luminescence beneath her proletarian facade. Through his lens, Jane undergoes a metaphysical transfiguration; a single photograph, captured with loosened tresses and ethereal draping, catapults her into the public consciousness as a paragon of beauty. This image, sent to a New York competition, secures her a prize that shatters her invisibility. Adopted and refined by Verstner, Jane returns to the social stage not as a domestic, but as a debutante, forcing a profound and belated psychological reckoning for John Adams, who finally perceives the diamond he once mistook for common coal.
Synopsis
John Adams is working his way through college. Jane is the little slavey in his boarding house. John at first has no idea of falling in love with Jane, but she is completely gone on him from the beginning. In fact, he has his eyes on Ethelda Rathbone, a young college girl. There came a time when John wanted to attend a ball at which Ethelda was to be present, but he hadn't a dress suit. Jane chanced to become aware of this, and with her scanty savings rented him one. Of course she couldn't tell him she did that, but she pretends that it was left there by a former boarder. So he goes to the ball. But boys will be boys, and his classmates rip the coat up his back, and he is compelled to come home without having seen Ethelda at all. Jane takes the suit back to the dealer, unaware that it is ruined. When the dealer discovers it, he demands payment. There follows a scene in the street in which she is humiliated. It was then that old Frederick Verstner, the town photographer and a man of considerable means, came to the crowd. Hearing her pitiful story, he made good the amount to the dealer. Shortly after this, Jane went to Verstner's to have her picture taken that she might give it to John. A newspaper in New York was offering a prize for the most beautiful photograph of a college girl, and Verstner's was crowded with girls from the school. Verstner took a picture of Jane, and, by loosening out her tresses and placing something filmy about her shoulders, he made her look beautiful. Through a course of circumstances, and without Jane's knowledge, this photograph is sent along with the others to the paper. And it wins the prize. Jane is, of course, as much surprised as the rest. And so is John. Verstner adopts the girl, educates her and makes her the most popular girl in the place. And then comes a great awakening for John.
Review Excerpt
"
The 1916 cinematic landscape was often characterized by a rigid adherence to moralistic tropes, yet within the framework of Plain Jane, directed under the meticulous supervision of Thomas H. Ince, we find a nuanced exploration of social stratification and the transformative power of the gaze. Written by the prolific C. Gardner Sullivan, the film operates as both a poignant melodrama and a scathing critique of the superficiality inherent in the American collegiate experience of the early 20th ce..."
