Arthur Stone stars as Cyril Fromage, the house detective of the Hotel Omigosh. Martha Sleeper is his sweetheart, the hotel switchboard operator, with Noah Young on board as the house manager.

Does Sherlock Sleuth hold up as a comedic relic worth unearthing? Short answer: yes, but only if you value frantic physical energy over a cohesive narrative.This film is specifically for historians of the silent era and fans of Hal Roach-style slapstick who enjoy seeing the logic of physics bent for a laugh. It is abso...

still_frame

still_frame

still_frame


Comparing the cinematic DNA and archive impact of two defining moments in cult history.

Ralph Ceder

Ralph Ince
Community
Log in to comment.
"Does Sherlock Sleuth hold up as a comedic relic worth unearthing? Short answer: yes, but only if you value frantic physical energy over a cohesive narrative.This film is specifically for historians of the silent era and fans of Hal Roach-style slapstick who enjoy seeing the logic of physics bent for a laugh. It is absolutely not for anyone seeking a grounded detective mystery or modern pacing.Quick Verdict: The Essentials1) This film works because the mechanical gags, particularly the switchboar..."
H.M. Walker
United States

