Summary
The pastoral façade of Ferryville's May Day revelry is pierced by an act of class-fueled mischief: the village's resident provocateur shoves Violet Henry, scion of the town's wealthiest lineage, into a murky pond. This spectacle, rather than causing outrage, elicits a perverse amusement from Millie Martin's parsimonious father, who, in an uncharacteristic display of generosity, bestows upon his ill-clad daughter a solitary dollar. Millie, yearning for a glimmer of sophistication before her inaugural railway journey, promptly allocates this newfound wealth to a pot of beauty cream. Her journey commences, setting the stage for an encounter with John Turner, a carpet layer by trade, now masquerading as a physician. Turner's impromptu medical career stems from a hasty escape: a poker game gone awry, a presumed fatality, and the opportunistic appropriation of his uncle's train ticket and doctor's satchel. A calculated feigned toothache from Millie is her gambit for John's attention, but her father's frugal instinct intervenes, prescribing chewing tobacco as a domestic panacea. When Millie inadvertently ingests the potent remedy, John, maintaining his medical charade, dramatically prescribes an immediate operation, leading the train to a nearby sanitarium. A subsequent escape by Millie, and John's discovery of her in a room cradling an infant, precipitates a flurry of mutual explanations. The misidentification of John as a burglar escalates the farce until the timely arrival of his uncle untangles the web of misunderstandings, finally liberating John and Millie to embark upon their burgeoning romance, free from the constraints of pretense and chaotic circumstance.
Synopsis
During the May Day celebration at Ferryville, Millie Martin, whose stingy father will not buy her proper clothes, watches as Violet Henry, the daughter of the town's richest man, is pushed into a stagnant pool by the village bolshevik. The story amuses Millie's father, who gives her a dollar, with which she buys beauty cream in preparation for her first railway journey. On the train, Millie meets John Turner, a carpet layer disguised as a doctor. Earlier, John fought a man caught cheating at poker. He took his uncle's railway ticket and doctor's bag when he thought the cheater was killed. After Millie feigns a toothache to get John's attention, her father, to avoid a doctor's bill, gives her chewing tobacco as a remedy. When she swallows it, and John orders an operation, the train stops at a nearby sanitarium. After Millie escapes, and John finds her in a room with a baby, they both explain. John is mistaken for a burglar, and after his uncle arrives to straighten matters out, John and Millie are free to pursue romance.
Review Excerpt
"
A Hilarious Diagnosis of Deception: Unpacking "When Doctors Disagree" (1919)
Stepping back into the silent era is often an exercise in historical appreciation, but every so often, a film emerges from the archives that transcends its temporal boundaries, speaking to universal human experiences with a wit and charm that remain undimmed. "When Doctors Disagree", a cinematic confection from 1919, is precisely such a treasure. It's a delightful concoction of mistaken identity, blos..."
