4.6/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 4.6/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. China Town My China Town remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
So, China Town My China Town. If you're coming to this one today, maybe for some historical context or just a morbid curiosity, know what you're in for. This isn't something for a casual Saturday morning cartoon binge. It's really for film historians, or folks who want to see how animation, and cultural depictions, used to be. Most everyone else? Yeah, you'll probably want to give it a pass. It’s a bit of a *rough* watch, to be frank.
The whole thing kicks off with a street scene that's just… a lot. You've got these characters, all very much caricatures, moving around. Their movements are so bouncy, almost like they're on springs, which is a Fleischer thing. But the details, like their outfits and expressions, they're really leaning into some heavy, heavy stereotypes. It's not subtle, not even for a second.
There's this sequence where a bunch of them are arguing. The way their mouths move, it's exaggerated. Like, way more than you'd expect. Their little fists are waving. It just goes on and on, this kind of rapid-fire, nonsensical chatter. You can tell the animators were just going for maximum visual noise here. It's not trying to tell a story so much as create a chaotic atmosphere, I guess. 😬
Then, suddenly, the arguing just stops. It just… pivots. And boom, we're into the song. The title song. It's a big, loud number. The whole scene comes alive with instruments popping up from nowhere, and the characters suddenly coordinating into this strange, almost unsettling dance routine. The transition is so abrupt it's almost funny, if the rest of it wasn't so… much.
I found myself focusing on little things. Like, one character has this tiny, perpetually bobbing head, even when everyone else is still. Or the way a prop, like a teapot, will suddenly grow or shrink for emphasis. It's the kind of early animation quirk that makes you squint, you know? Like, did they mean for that to happen?
The animation style itself, it's classic Fleischer. It's got that rubber hose feel, everything bends and squishes. But here, applied to these specific characters and this setting, it gives everything an almost *unreal* quality. Like a bad dream someone had about a neighborhood. The whole thing feels very much like a product of its time, which is the only real way to look at it now. It's a relic.
It's interesting to see how far animation has come. How much care goes into character design and representation now. This short, it's a stark reminder of what used to pass for entertainment. It's not really a pleasant experience. More of a historical document, really.
Don't go in expecting anything modern or sensitive. This is a very old cartoon. And it shows its age, in more ways than one. *Big* time.

IMDb 6.9
1919
Community
Log in to comment.