DbcultAccessing Vault...
Cult Review
Senior Film Conservator
If you are looking for something to watch on a rainy Tuesday while eating toast, this might be it. It is for people who love old-school drama where people stare intensely into the middle distance. If you hate slow movies where the plot is mostly people talking in rooms, you will probably want to skip this one. 🍿
It is worth watching today if only to see how much we haven't changed. We still love stories about rich people being messy.
The movie follows Elena, played by Agnès Aranis. She has a "checkered past" which in 1930s movie talk usually means she did something slightly rebellious once. She ends up working as a maid for this very posh family.
Of course, the son of the house falls in love with her. His name is Juan, and he has that very specific 1930s hair that looks like it was painted on with shoe polish.
There is a scene early on where Elena is just dusting a vase. She looks so nervous, like the vase might explode. It is a small thing but you can tell she is carrying a lot of weight on her shoulders.
The house itself feels like a character. It is huge and cold. You can almost feel the draft coming off the screen. ❄️
Eventually, they have a baby. Back then, this was a huge deal for a maid and a rich son. The movie treats the baby like a ticking time bomb of social shame.
I noticed that the lighting gets really dark whenever Elena thinks about her past. It is not subtle. It is like the director is poking you in the eye saying "Look! She is sad!"
One thing that kept me watching was Carlos Villarías. He has this presence that makes you feel like something spooky is about to happen, even when it is just a dinner scene. He is much more interesting than the lead guy.
The pacing is a bit weird. Some scenes go on forever. Like, do we really need to see them walk across the entire garden? Probably not.
But then other things happen so fast. Suddenly there is a baby. Then suddenly there is a confrontation. It is high burstiness for sure.
It reminds me a little bit of the family vibes in Penrod, but way more depressing. While that one feels like childhood, this feels like consequences.
There is a moment where Elena holds the baby and just looks at a closed door. The silence in that shot is actually pretty good. It lasted about five seconds too long, but it worked.
The script has some clunky lines. Someone says something about "the mud we are made of" and it sounds like they are reading a poem they don't understand. 📖
I wonder if the actors were tired during the night scenes. Juan Torena looks like he needs a very long nap in the middle of the big argument.
It is not a perfect movie. The ending feels a bit rushed, like they ran out of film or the sun was going down and they had to go home.
If you like movies like His Private Life, you will find the class stuff here very familiar. It is the same old story of people being told who they can and cannot love.
The costumes are actually pretty great. The dresses the rich women wear look heavy enough to sink a boat. Elena’s maid outfit is so stiff it probably stood up on its own in the dressing room.
I liked the music, even if it was a bit screechy at the high parts. It adds to that melodramatic vibe that you just can't get in modern movies.
Sometimes the movie feels like it’s trying too hard to be a tragedy. But then a character will do something human, like trip slightly or fumble a glass, and it feels real again.
The baby actor was surprisingly chill. Usually, movie babies are screaming their heads off, but this one just kind of stared at the camera like it knew the plot was ridiculous. 👶
Anyway, it is a decent watch if you want to see how Hollywood handled Spanish-language stories back in the day. It’s got heart, even if it’s a bit soggy.
Don't expect a masterpiece. Just expect a story about a girl who made some choices and a family that didn't know how to handle it.
It’s fine. It’s more than fine, actually. It’s just... very 1930.
IMDb —
1915
Community
Log in to comment.
