DbcultAccessing Vault...
Cult Review
Archivist John
Senior Editor
Short answer: Yes, but its exploration of mid-1930s New York and its social dynamics makes it a must-watch for history buffs and film enthusiasts.
Is this film worth your time today? Absolutely, but it’s not for everyone. If you’re a fan of 1930s cinema, particularly those interested in the social and economic shifts of the era, you’ll find much to appreciate. Conversely, if you’re looking for a modern blockbuster, you might find 'Fifth Avenue' to be a bit of a journey back in time.
This film works because of its nuanced portrayal of the 1930s social landscape, particularly the tensions between the wealthy elite and those from more humble backgrounds. The chemistry between Anna May Wong and Allan Forrest as their characters navigate misunderstandings and love makes for compelling viewing. The film's pacing, while sometimes slow, allows for a rich exploration of the characters' lives.
This film fails because it occasionally relies on stereotypes and misunderstandings that can feel dated. The plot’s reliance on a misunderstanding and a police raid to create tension can feel contrived. Additionally, the film's pacing in the earlier scenes can be overly slow, which might frustrate viewers seeking a faster-paced narrative.
You should watch it if you’re interested in 1930s American cinema and its depiction of social class, love, and misunderstandings. The film’s exploration of these themes, combined with its star power, makes it a worthwhile watch for history enthusiasts and film scholars.
Anna May Wong, known for her roles in films that often cast her in stereotypical roles, delivers a nuanced performance as Barbara Pelham. Her chemistry with Allan Forrest as Neil is palpable, and their scenes together are some of the film’s highlights. Forrest also shines, bringing a level of charm and sincerity to his character. The supporting cast, including Josephine Norman and Marguerite De La Motte, provide further depth to the story.
Under the direction of Frank Lloyd, 'Fifth Avenue' has a polished and deliberate style. Lloyd's attention to detail in the set design and the portrayal of New York City in the 1930s is commendable. However, the pacing can be a bit slow at times, which might not suit all viewers. The film’s focus on the characters’ internal journeys and social dynamics is effective but can feel drawn out.
The cinematography by Karl Struss is a standout element of the film. The scenes set in New York City, particularly those depicting the bustling streets and the elegance of Mrs. Kemp’s home, are visually striking. The use of lighting and color helps to create a sense of atmosphere and mood, adding to the film's overall quality.
The pacing of 'Fifth Avenue' can be a bit uneven. While the film excels in its exploration of the characters' internal conflicts and social dynamics, the slower moments can feel disjointed. The film’s reliance on misunderstandings and a police raid to create tension can sometimes feel contrived, especially in the earlier scenes.
The tone of 'Fifth Avenue' is mostly serious and contemplative. The film doesn't shy away from the social and economic realities of the time, making for a poignant and thought-provoking viewing experience. However, the film’s tone can sometimes feel heavy, which might make it less accessible to some viewers.
While 'Fifth Avenue' may not be for everyone, it is a film that offers a unique glimpse into the social and economic dynamics of 1930s America. Its nuanced portrayal of characters and the exploration of themes like class and love make it a worthwhile watch for those interested in the era. However, the film’s slower pace and reliance on stereotypes might make it less appealing to those seeking a faster-paced narrative.
Pros:
Cons:
It works. But it’s flawed. 'Fifth Avenue' offers a unique and thought-provoking look into mid-1930s America, but its reliance on stereotypes and slow pacing might make it less appealing to some viewers. Still, for those interested in the era and its social dynamics, this film is a must-watch.
IMDb —
1920
Community
Log in to comment.
