4.9/10
Senior Film Conservator

A definitive 4.9/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Hurdy Gurdy remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
Okay, "Hurdy Gurdy" is a real trip back in time. If you have even a passing interest in early animation, especially Oswald the Lucky Rabbit, you should absolutely give this a watch. For folks expecting super polished modern animation, you might find it a bit… *different*.
It kicks off with an organ grinder and his little monkey doing their thing on the street. All pretty standard until the monkey decides a big ol' wad of bubblegum is a fantastic idea. It is, predictably, _not_ a fantastic idea. 😅
That gum gets *enormous*, completely swallowing the little dancer. So, of course, Oswald steps in. He’s got to fill in for the monkey, that’s just how these things work.
The whole short just feels so wonderfully *chaotic* and inventive for its time. Oswald’s energy is really something else, even in black and white, silent (mostly) film.
There’s this moment where Oswald tries to play the hurdy-gurdy, and it practically takes on a life of its own. The musical notes actually jump out and form little shapes, bouncing around. It’s a super silly visual gag, but it totally works.
You really notice how much pure physical comedy they packed into these few minutes. Nobody held back. The slapstick feels almost *aggressive* sometimes, in the best way possible.
The monkey, once it finally gets unstuck from the gum, seems to hold a pretty serious grudge. There’s a quick chase sequence that's just pure, unadulterated, classic cartoon mayhem. 🏃💨
It’s not trying to be deep, not even a little bit. Just pure, silly fun for a few minutes. The backgrounds are pretty sparse, but the characters really pop. Oswald's expressions are already so lively, you can almost feel him reacting.
Honestly, it’s a super quick watch, maybe five minutes tops. Perfect for a coffee break or just a curious peek into cartoon history. Don't go in expecting some grand narrative or emotional journey. It’s a monkey, some gum, and Oswald trying to make some music. What else could you possibly need? It's pretty *bold* for a 1929 cartoon, really.

IMDb —
1920
Community
Log in to comment.