Cult Review
Senior Film Conservator

If you have about an hour to kill and you want to see a horse that is actually smarter than half the people you know, this is worth a watch. Honestly, it's mostly for people who like old Westerns or just want to see why Tom Mix was such a massive deal back then.
If you can't stand silent movies or you need a plot that isn't predictable by the five-minute mark, you'll probably hate this. It’s very much a product of its time, but in a way that feels kind of cozy.
I watched this on a Tuesday morning with some cold coffee, and it weirdly hit the spot. Tom Mix has this vibe where he’s clearly a performer first and an actor second, but it works.
He wears these outfits that are so white and crisp. It’s funny because he’s supposed to be an outlaw on the run, but he looks like he just stepped out of a dry cleaner. 🌵
The plot is about Tom being framed, which, yeah, we've seen that a thousand times. But the way he moves and the stunts he does—no stunt doubles here—is actually impressive even now.
There is this one scene where he’s jumping onto Tony the Horse that made me jump a little. It’s so fluid and fast.
Speaking of the horse, Tony is the real lead of this movie. He does things that don't even seem possible for a horse, like nudging Tom at the exact right moment to wake him up.
I think there was a moment where the horse basically untied a rope? I might have imagined that, but honestly, with Tony, it’s believable.
Al Ferguson plays the bad guy, and he’s got that classic silent movie villain face. He sneers a lot. A lot.
It’s almost funny how much he sneers, like his face might just get stuck that way. He’s much more fun to watch than some of the villains in It Happened Out West, even if that one is a bit more modern.
The girl in the movie, Sally Blane, is mostly there to look worried and be saved. She’s good at looking worried, I guess, but she doesn't have much to do.
I found myself zoning out during the scenes where they talk about the "plot" details. The title cards are a bit long-winded sometimes.
One card stayed on screen for so long I actually checked my phone to see if the video had frozen. It hadn't; it just wanted me to really, really read those three sentences.
It’s strange to think this came out the same year as The New Babylon. That movie feels like it’s from a different dimension compared to this simple cowboy story.
While that one is all artsy and intense, Outlawed is just... a guy and his horse. It’s simple, and there’s something nice about that.
The landscape looks like the typical California-as-the-Old-West locations. You can almost feel the dust, even if Tom Mix’s hat stays perfectly clean the whole time.
There’s a chase through some rocky terrain that is actually shot pretty well. The camera stays wide so you can see the speed of the horses.
I hate when modern movies use too many close-ups during action. Here, you get to see everything, and it makes the stunts feel real.
There's a bit of a subplot with a guy named Barney Furey that I didn't quite follow. He’s just kind of there, being a character actor.
The writing by Helen Gregg and George W. Pyper isn't going to win any awards, but it gets the job done. It’s like they knew exactly what the audience wanted: Tom, the horse, and a few punches.
I noticed one extra in the background of a town scene who was just staring directly at the camera for a solid three seconds. It made me laugh. 🤠
It reminds me of the low-budget charm you see in stuff like Fast and Fearless. It’s not trying to be a masterpiece.
The ending is exactly what you think it is. Everything gets wrapped up in a neat little bow, and Tom probably rides off into the sunset.
I wish they had more scenes of Tony the Horse doing tricks. I’d watch a 90-minute movie of just that horse solving crimes.
Is it a great film? Probably not. But it’s a good time, especially if you appreciate the craft of the late silent era.
The prints of these old movies are usually a bit scratchy, which adds to the vibe. It feels like you're watching a piece of history that survived by accident.
If you’re looking for something deep, maybe go watch a documentary or something. But if you want to see a man in a giant hat do cool things, this is it.
It’s a bit better than The Beauty Shop if we’re talking about pure entertainment value. At least for me.
Anyway, I liked it more than I expected to. Even with the cheesy mustache-twirling.

IMDb 6
1919
Community
Log in to comment.