Rose of the Tenements Review: Gangsters, Orphans, and Revolution in 1920s New York

Short answer: Yes, but it's a complex and nuanced character study that might not be for everyone. Rose of the Tenements delves into the lives of orphans in 1920s New York, their rise through the ranks of the underworld, and the political turmoil that surrounds them. This film is a character-driven noir that offers a rich tapestry of themes, but its pacing might be slow for those looking for a fast-paced action flick.

This film works because...

The character development in Rose of the Tenements is exceptional. Both Rose and Danny are complex characters with distinct motivations and backgrounds that come together to create a compelling narrative. The performances, especially from James Gordon and Evelyn Selbie, are nuanced and layered, bringing depth to their respective arcs.

The setting of the lower East Side in the 1920s is vividly depicted, giving the film a gritty realism that enhances the storytelling. The cinematography by Sidney Franklin effectively captures the atmosphere of the time, from the bustling streets to the dimly lit back alleys.

This film fails because...

The pacing of the film can be slow, which might be a turn-off for modern audiences. The political and social commentary, while relevant, can sometimes feel heavy-handed and didactic. The film's exploration of revolution and political activism, while interesting, can be overly simplistic in its portrayal of the Bolsheviks and their ideals.

Cinematic perspective: Exploring the visual vocabulary of Rose of the Tenements (1926) through its definitive frames.

The film's reliance on melodrama and over-the-top situations might feel dated to contemporary viewers. While the character arcs are well-developed, the melodramatic elements can become tiresome, especially in scenes of political agitation and bomb-throwing.

You should watch it if...

You are a fan of character-driven dramas that explore the complexities of human nature and the social issues of the early 20th century. If you appreciate nuanced performances and a rich, detailed historical setting, Rose of the Tenements is a film that offers a lot to ponder. It might be a less exciting watch for those who prefer more straightforward narratives or those who are not interested in the historical context of 1920s New York.

Is this film worth watching?

Rose of the Tenements is a film that rewards viewers with its depth and character development. While it might not be everyone's cup of tea, it offers a unique glimpse into the world of 1920s New York and the lives of its marginalized residents. If you are willing to invest time in a character-driven narrative that explores the intersection of personal and political struggles, this film is definitely worth your time.

Key Takeaways

• Best for: Fans of character-driven dramas, historical settings, and nuanced performances.
• Not for: Viewers seeking fast-paced action or melodrama.
• Standout element: The detailed and realistic portrayal of 1920s New York City.
• Biggest flaw: The slow pacing and sometimes heavy-handed political commentary.

Pros and Cons

• Pros:
  • Nuanced character development
  • Rich historical setting
  • Exceptional performances
  • Engaging narrative
• Cons:
  • Slow pacing
  • Occasionally heavy-handed political commentary
  • Overly melodramatic situations

Verdict

It works. But it’s flawed. Rose of the Tenements is a film that offers a deep dive into the lives of orphans in 1920s New York, providing a rich and nuanced character study. While it might not be for everyone, its strengths in character development and historical detail make it a worthwhile watch for those interested in mid-20th century American history and its social issues. If you can appreciate a slower, more character-driven narrative, this film is a must-watch.