DbcultAccessing Vault...
6.1/10
Senior Film Conservator
A definitive 6.1/10 rating for a film that redefined the boundaries of cult cinema. Rudareva sreca remains a cornerstone of transgressive art.
If you have a spare hour and want to see what 1929 in Southeast Serbia looked like, Rudareva sreca is worth a click. It is not exactly a thrill ride.
I think people who love historical textures and seeing real locations will dig this. If you are looking for a fast plot, you are going to hate it within five minutes.
The whole thing feels very close to the ground. There is no Hollywood shine here, just a lot of men with very tired eyes looking at rocks.
The movie starts out showing the daily grind. It is slow. Like, really slow.
You see the miners working and you can almost smell the damp earth and the old sweat. The director clearly wanted us to feel how heavy those shovels were.
I kept thinking about The Mints of Hell while watching the industrial scenes. Both movies have this obsession with the way work looks on a person's body.
The boss in this movie is such a cartoon villain but in a weirdly realistic way. He has this smug look that makes you want to shove him into one of his own mine shafts.
He exploits the workers, and you can see the anger building up in the cast. Cedomir Pencic has this very steady, quiet way of acting that I liked.
He does not do the big, wide-eyed silent movie gestures. He just looks done with everything.
Eventually, the miners decide they have had enough. They quit. They want to succeed on their own terms.
This part of the movie feels a bit like a dream. It is very optimistic for a film about people who have nothing but their tools.
I noticed the scenery a lot more in the second half. Southeast Serbia looks beautiful even in grainy black and white.
The mountains feel like their own character. Sometimes the camera just lingers on a ridge for a few seconds too long, but I didn't mind.
It reminded me of the pacing in The Block Signal, where the environment starts to matter as much as the people. Though that one had more trains.
There is a scene where they are sitting around talking about their future. You can see one guy in the back who keeps looking at the camera and then looking away really fast.
I love those little mistakes in old films. It reminds you these were just real people trying to figure out how to make a movie.
The editing is a bit jumpy. Sometimes a scene ends and you are not sure how much time has passed.
Is it the next day? Is it a week later? The movie doesn't really care to tell you.
The "luck" mentioned in the title feels more like stubbornness. I don't think they got lucky, I think they just worked until their hands bled.
It is much more grounded than something like The Raven. There is no theatrical gloom here, just the actual gloom of a dark mine.
The writer—who isn't even credited in my notes—didn't go for big speeches. The title cards are simple and to the point.
I wonder if the actors were actually miners. Some of them move like they have been doing this their whole lives.
Bata Nikolic has a great face for this kind of thing. He looks like he was carved out of a piece of coal himself.
It gets a little repetitive near the end. We get it, they are working hard. We saw the shovels already.
But then there is a shot of the sunset or the horizon and you forgive the movie for being a bit dull. It has a soul.
I wouldn't say this is a masterpiece. It is more like a moving photograph of a time that is long gone.
If you are bored of modern movies that feel like they were made in a computer, this is a good palate cleanser. It is very, very human.
The ending is a bit abrupt. It just... stops. No big wrap-up, no grand finale. They just keep going.
Maybe that is the point. The luck is just being able to keep working for yourself instead of a jerk.
Anyway, it's a quiet film. Watch it when you don't feel like thinking too hard but want to see something real.
One of the miners has a mustache that is definitely not symmetrical. It drove me crazy for ten minutes. And the way the light flickers in the indoor scenes makes it feel like the whole world is shaking. It’s probably just the old film stock, but it adds a weird energy to the tension with the boss.
Also, the music in the version I saw was a bit too upbeat for a movie about mining. It felt like it belonged in Don't Flirt rather than a gritty drama about labor. But that’s the risk with these old silents, you never know what score you’re gonna get.
IMDb —
1925
Community
Log in to comment.
