DbcultAccessing Vault...
Cult Review
Senior Film Conservator
If you really love the 1920s vibe—the big hats, the flickering film grain, and the specific way people used to talk with their eyes—then yeah, give it a go. It’s a short watch and it doesn't ask much of you.
But if you hate movies where the main woman’s only goal is to turn a guy into a 'real man,' you’re probably gonna want to skip this one. It’s very much a product of its time in that regard. 🙄
It’s not quite as weird or experimental as Ballet mécanique, but it has that late-20s polish that makes it easy to look at. The office sets are actually pretty neat.
Jacqueline Logan plays Joyce, and she is honestly too good for this movie. She’s an efficient secretary who seems like she could run a whole company by herself.
Instead, she spends her time worrying about Jimmy. Jimmy is a stock clerk who is just... not good at anything. 📉
William Collier Jr. plays him with this sort of permanent slouch. You just want to reach into the screen and tell him to stand up straight and do his work.
There is this one scene in the office where he fumbles with a bunch of papers. Joyce just watches him with this expression that’s half-love and half-pity.
It’s a look a lot of us have probably given someone we should have broken up with months ago. It felt very real for a movie from 1929.
Thelma Todd is in this, which was the main reason I wanted to watch it. I’ve always liked her energy in the early talkies and late silents.
But she doesn’t really get to do much here. It’s a bit of a letdown if you’re a fan of hers.
She’s mostly just there to fill out the world. It’s kind of like watching a great athlete sit on the bench for the whole game.
I found myself wishing the movie would go off on a tangent with her character instead of focusing on Jimmy’s latest failure. It’s not as dramatic as something like The Living Corpse, but it tries to be.
So, Joyce finally gets fed up and they separate. Good for her, honestly. 👏
Then the movie does that thing where it says 'Two Years Later' and everything has changed. It feels very fast.
Jimmy comes back and he’s supposedly a new man. He vows to be worthy of her and all that stuff.
I didn’t really buy it. Maybe I’m just cynical, but it felt like the writers just needed a happy ending and didn't care if it made sense.
It reminds me a bit of the melodrama in Destiny's Toy, where people change their entire personalities just because the script says it’s time.
The whole thing feels a bit like a rehearsal for the bigger dramas that would come in the 1930s. It’s caught between the silent era’s big gestures and the talkies' more grounded feel.
I kept thinking about Day Dreams while watching it. That one feels more honest about struggle, even if it’s totally different.
The Bachelor Girl is just a bit too clean. Even when Jimmy is supposed to be on a 'downward path,' his hair still looks pretty good.
It’s a movie that feels like it was written by people who had very nice offices and didn't really know what a 'downward path' actually looked like.
Still, it’s not a bad way to spend an afternoon. It’s like eating a plain cracker—not super exciting, but it does the job if you’re hungry for some vintage cinema.
I wouldn't go out of my way to find it, but if you stumble across it, it's fine. It’s just... fine.
Just don't expect it to change your life or anything. It's just a story about a girl who needs better taste in men. 🤷♀️
IMDb 6.2
1918
Community
Log in to comment.
